5 ms·
This is why web services should be open source and available for self hosting: - The geeks with the know-how to run a Web server benefit from your product for
by nerdponx 10y ago
This is why web services should be open source and available for self hosting:
- The geeks with the know-how to run a Web server benefit from your product for free, but in exchange you get bug reports, patches, etc.
- Everyone else pays, because you also offer a paid hosting option.
But because the product is fundamentally open source and federated, it can and hopefully will outlive its original developer.
- devoply 10y agoGoing open source does not save any project. It's just a different way of doing things. If the project is not profitable, it will still go under while being open source with a hosted business model. The question is does this sort of model work with _your_ project. There have been open source projects that used it just as marketing tool and then shut down the open source version when they grew popular enough. There have been those which have severely limited the open source version to get people to buy the premium version which is hosted. At the end you are dealing with locusts, they will consume anything of value to them for free without giving a damn about its implications to the future survival of the product. Altruism is nice, but it's not business savvy.
- camkego 10y agoThe comparison to locusts is quite beautiful.
- dkyc 10y agoMy experience running a project/company like you describe: 1) Not the geeks, but the big multinational companies with disposable developer time end up using your open-source solution. Exactly the types of users I don't feel sorry for and would rather extract money from. 2) The "payback" in the form of bug reports and patches is negligible, because nobody likes to do work if they're not being compensated (either through money, or, more commonly in the open-source world, fame) 3) The users of the hosted version don't want to pay anything because "it's open-source, after all". 4) People that do not have the necessary technical capabilities to host your software, but also don't like to pay, harass you on GitHub and other support channels because "your software doesn't work", and it "throws error messages". The key advantage is that some people (journalists, bloggers) tend to present you in a more positive light if you describe yourself as an "open-source solution" rather than yet another commercial app.
- oblio 10y agoOpen Core for the win. You want to use the base functionalities? Be my guest. You want Single Sign On through LDAP, AD, etc.? Commercial edition. You want advanced user management and permissions, etc.? Commercial edition. You want the product to work behind a NTLM proxy? Commercial edition. You want to use your own domain name (if hosted)? Commercial edition. There's a handful of requests that are sure-sign markers that someone is using the product in a corporate environment. Of course, if the people asking for those features also provide a pull request that complies with the project's pull request guidelines, then in that case, things might change. Though it's quite rare that such a huge feature as AD integration is actually provided by a project outsider (especially one that also comes with good code coverage, respects project coding conventions, etc.).
- user5994461 10y agoOr open demo for the win. Everything is paid. Except there is a free edition for up to N users, or non-production use. This lets people try the product, demo and experiment.
- eloisant 10y agoThere are 2 issues with that: - People who only need basic functionalities don't bring any money - People who need paid functionalities don't get to try them in the free version So as much I as like free tiers as a user, for a business I think "free trial" is the way to go.
- majkinetor 10y agoPeople who only need basic funcs provide you testing, i.e. product stability i.e. money.
- nerdponx 10y agoCan #1 be mitigated with a provision in the software license? "Free for personal use only" kind of thing.