3 ms·
> Some of the ways to look at it is that if providers can sell a fastlane to Netflix they can reduce prices for the consumer. Other arguments that have been adv
by tzs 10y ago
> Some of the ways to look at it is that if providers can sell a fastlane to Netflix they can reduce prices for the consumer. Other arguments that have been advanced include having a fast lane for medical devices or emergency services.
I don't have a problem (with one big reservation) with that PROVIDED that the "fast lane" is faster than the service that the consumer is paying for. For example, supposed I am paying for 20 mbit/second network service from my ISP, and I subscribe to a video streaming service that offers streams at two resolutions. One takes 15 mbit/second and one takes 30 mbit/second. I wish to watch a 2 hour movie stream. Assume that my data cap is high enough that I will not be going anywhere near it.
If the video service wants to pay my ISP to give me 30 mbit/second when I view their higher definition streams, I can see that being OK from a network regulation point of view. (It may not be OK from an antitrust point of view, but that is out of scope).
The lower definition stream, though, is only 15 mbit/second. That's below the 20 mbit/second my IPS sold me, so I'd not be OK with it if the video service had to buy a "fast lane" to make the 15 mbit/second stream work.
For the "fast lane" scenario I described in the first paragraph, where it is faster than the service I'm paying for, I do have one big reservation. There needs to be something in place to ensure that the base service is reasonable. I do not want to see the ISPs advertise their base service as something ridiculously low, like 1 mbit/second, and throttle everything down to that except from sites that have paid for a "fast lane".
The above is also how I would approach "zero rating" and "sponsored data". In summary, these would be my network rules:
1. the ISP must provide the data rate and cap (if any) that the consumer has paid for.
2. The user can use that for whatever they want, with no throttling or blocking by the ISP (other than reasonable network management, such as to deal with congestion).
3. If the ISP wants to provide something beyond what the consumer paid for at no charge to the consumer that's fine, including allowing others to pay the ISP to give the consumer that extra service.
- amazon_not 10y ago#3 is basically zero rating, which is another form of discrimination, a way for the ISP to play gatekeeper and favorites. We, as a society, do not want that. As to dynamic bandwidth offerings, there is no need for the content provider to pay for this or administer it. They are an unnecessary layer of friction. The ISP can provide a portal for the end customer to self provision whatever bandwidth they want.