5 ms·
If you think Ayn Rand is an insightful novelist, then ST:NG probably isn't going to be your preferred brand of entertainment. I think Rand may be the single mo
by mindcrime 10y ago
If you think Ayn Rand is an insightful novelist, then ST:NG probably isn't going to be your preferred brand of entertainment.
I think Rand may be the single most important novelist in recent history, but I love Star Trek:TNG. And honestly, I'm not seeing much connection between those two things. Maybe you could expand on how you think they relate?
- twblalock 10y agoIts pretty obvious that the Federation is collectivist and has many characteristics of idealized post-state communism. In many of the episodes, greed or money are motivators of the less-advanced species or the adversary. There are some choice quotes here: http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Money http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Money
- jessaustin 10y ago"Post-state"? They're flying around the galaxy in giant war machines and observe a strict militarist command hierarchy. It takes more than a village to hire Boeing and Lockheed. I doubt this is what Kropotkin had in mind...
- twblalock 10y agoI didn't say the Federation was post-state. I said it had many characteristics of post-state communism. These include: - No money -- everything is free - Housing provided for free - A post-scarcity society in which civilians do not need to work and are free to pursue their own interests - Complete social equality for civilians (who are outside the military chain of command) The existence of a military is not one of the post-state communist features, but on balance, society in Star Trek is closer to post-state communism than any real communist society has ever been. Besides, even the "military" is supposed to be for exploration and not war, according to the statements of the characters in the show.
- dragonwriter 10y agoAyn Rand's novels are not-even-veiled polemic for objectivist politico-economic ideology, whereas ST:TNG is grounded in (though not, mostly, polemic for) a nearly diametrically opposed ideology. So, there's probably some tension between appreciation of those two things.
- btilly 10y agoI have many objectivists among my friends. They love ST:TNG nearly universally. Yes, they recognize their political disagreements with the show's system. But the show is not in your face about it and they don't care about it. Actual people who subscribe to a philosophy don't generally look like the cardboard cutouts that we might imagine based on our personal knowledge of said philosophy.
- dragonwriter 10y agoYeah, I'd don't disagree that the original claim of incompatibility was overstated; it's quite easy to enjoy ST:TNG without agreeing with Roddenberry's political philosophy, because, again, while it shapes the background and stories to some extent, the work isn't heavy-handed polemic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 10y agoAnd honestly, I'm not seeing much connection between those two things. I view the economic philosophy of the two to be contradictory. Though I suppose one could argue that a post-scarcity economy would be a Randian dream (one is now truly free to does as one wishes without bowing to the necessity of collecting resources and the social structures that go with that), I think ST:TNG would eliminate the imagined need for Rand to have written anything at all.
- st3v3r 10y agoProbably because the world of TNG, at least that of the Federation, is the diametric opposite of the Randian universe?
- mindcrime 10y agoIs it really though? Like somebody else said, they don't really expose a lot of the "behind the scenes" details of the political system of that world. I mean, most of the scenes are set on a military vessel and isolated to a small snippet of the overall society. I think it's dangerous to assume too much about the Federation world as a whole. OTOH, it's been years, if not decades, since I watched, so maybe there's more of that than I'm remembering.