5 ms·
I kind of skimmed the article, mainly because I can't be bothered to care about the topic, but I didn't see where Theil "fears" _Star Trek_. But let's run with
by mikestew 10y ago
I kind of skimmed the article, mainly because I can't be bothered to care about the topic, but I didn't see where Theil "fears" _Star Trek_. But let's run with that: why does Mr. Theil fear _Star Trek_? Because that world doesn't need Peter Theil. If you think Ayn Rand is an insightful novelist, then ST:NG probably isn't going to be your preferred brand of entertainment.
But it seems to me the article misses the mark in that it assumes Theil to be a "tech guy". Meh, I dunno, I kind of view him as a "money guy" who happened to bet on some tech companies. It's a cherry-picked (by me) quote, but:
"In 2011, for instance, he told George Packer that he did not consider the iPhone a technological breakthrough. 'Compare this with the Apollo space program'"
The Apollo space program, which ended before most people were born (or thereabouts), affected our lives in a peripheral manner if at all. Tang, Velcro, and a big swinging "if we can put a man on the moon, we can put an ICBM on your capitol" dick to show for it. Umm, thanks, I guess. Too bad there's no real follow-through fifty years later. The "super-computer-in-your-pocket", OTOH, changed the way people live their lives (and, granted, not all for the better). I don't ask for directions, I don't have a land line, and any question I might have ("what octane fuel goes in this car?", "where's the fuse box on this thing?") can be answered instantly.
So I guess I don't care which side Theil takes in the "Star Wars/Star Trek" nerd battle.
- tyingq 10y ago>I didn't see where Theil "fears" _Star Trek_. It was hard to find. Here's where they finally state their case: "What is anathema to Thiel in “Star Trek” is the notion, drawn from Isaac Asimov’s fiction, that the market is but a temporary solution to imbalances in supply and demand, and that technology and plenty will eventually make it obsolete" So, he "fears" that capitalism will go away...according the them anyway. They seem to source some of that thought from what they call his "Cato Essay", here: https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education-libertarian https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/educatio...
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoOnly a wealthy capitalist could see a downside to their relative wealth being diminished as technology and trade ensures that all necessities for human life are provided as human rights. But I guess some middle class people always dream of being the one great king who isn't starving.
- norikki 10y agoBashing "wealthy capitalists"? Declaring most of my hard-earned paycheck to be someone else's "human right"? Attacking the middle class for not being receptive to class warfare rhetoric? Hopefully you can see why Thiel might characterize these sorts of opinions about the future as Marxist ideology, long ago discredited by history.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoGo back enough time and we're all just hunting and gathering for our next meal. There is no wealth, just our health, until we die. You put many words in my mouth, so I am unable to respond to them without legitimizing the incorrect. All I ask: is this, the world and structure of it, truly the best that humanity can accomplish? Or were we misled on a guided path by powers that preferred the world to fit according to a scheme that benefited them? Can we do better? Can we dream of a world of shared prosperity precisely without the benefits to one coming from another's hard-earned paycheck. I do not advocate for a return to a system that did not work (Russian/Soviet state managed economy, I assume you mean to say), but rather that we should not simply give up and assume the world we have is the best we can come up with. Our ancient ancestors overcame great adversity to build a better future unrecognizable from their present day, as did our distant ancestors, as did our grandparents, as did our parents, and so can we.
- mindcrime 10y agoIf you think Ayn Rand is an insightful novelist, then ST:NG probably isn't going to be your preferred brand of entertainment. I think Rand may be the single most important novelist in recent history, but I love Star Trek:TNG. And honestly, I'm not seeing much connection between those two things. Maybe you could expand on how you think they relate?
- twblalock 10y agoIts pretty obvious that the Federation is collectivist and has many characteristics of idealized post-state communism. In many of the episodes, greed or money are motivators of the less-advanced species or the adversary. There are some choice quotes here: http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Money http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Money
- jessaustin 10y ago"Post-state"? They're flying around the galaxy in giant war machines and observe a strict militarist command hierarchy. It takes more than a village to hire Boeing and Lockheed. I doubt this is what Kropotkin had in mind...
- twblalock 10y agoI didn't say the Federation was post-state. I said it had many characteristics of post-state communism. These include: - No money -- everything is free - Housing provided for free - A post-scarcity society in which civilians do not need to work and are free to pursue their own interests - Complete social equality for civilians (who are outside the military chain of command) The existence of a military is not one of the post-state communist features, but on balance, society in Star Trek is closer to post-state communism than any real communist society has ever been. Besides, even the "military" is supposed to be for exploration and not war, according to the statements of the characters in the show.
- dragonwriter 10y agoAyn Rand's novels are not-even-veiled polemic for objectivist politico-economic ideology, whereas ST:TNG is grounded in (though not, mostly, polemic for) a nearly diametrically opposed ideology. So, there's probably some tension between appreciation of those two things.
- endorphone 10y agoYou left a four paragraph reply after beginning by announcing that you hadn't read the article, then ending by saying you don't care regardless. Those are strange motivations. In any case, Thiel has outright declared Star Trek communism, and Star Wars capitalism. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/11/fashion/peter-thiel-confirm-or-deny.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/11/fashion/peter-thiel-confi...
- mikestew 10y agoYou left a four paragraph reply after beginning by announcing that you hadn't read the article, then ending by saying you don't care regardless. Those are strange motivations. Boy, nothing slips past you, eh? Were I to give an honest self-assessment, it's because the article I didn't care about (but did, in fact, read albeit skimmed) gave me a jumping off point to talk about what I want to talk about. It's a common human affliction.
- chrishacken 10y ago> The Apollo space program, which ended before most people were born (or thereabouts), affected our lives in a peripheral manner if at all. Tang, Velcro, and a big swinging "if we can put a man on the moon, we can put an ICBM on your capitol" dick to show for it. Umm, thanks, I guess. Too bad there's no real follow-through fifty years later. That's an extremely pessimistic view on it. Space exploration has created tens of thousand of new materials, science, and products as a result. The biggest impact that it made was in the hearts and minds of young children that grew up dreaming to be scientists and astronauts that would one-day go to space. Our society has lost that vision for the most part.
- hguant 10y ago>The Apollo space program, which ended before most people were born (or thereabouts), affected our lives in a peripheral manner if at all. Tang, Velcro, and a big swinging "if we can put a man on the moon, we can put an ICBM on your capitol" dick to show for it. Umm, thanks, I guess. Too bad there's no real follow-through fifty years later. This comment shows a lot of ignorance about the importance of the space program in general, and Apollo in particular. From this[1] answer on StackExchange: Here are some Apollo specific innovations: microchip, cordless tools, joystick, CAT scans, technology in MRI machines, modern shoe designs, freeze dried food, vacuum sealed packages, dampening material, retro-reflector (detects chemical leaks), water purification, silicon based storage of records, fly-by-wire, ground water cleaning, large fabric roofs used in landmark buildings, anti-tip rafts, insulation blankets, and countless others. Here's a link to the NASA spinoff technology data base: https://spinoff.nasa.gov/spinoff/database/ https://spinoff.nasa.gov/spinoff/database/ The iPhone was revolutionary in a particular field. The space program was revolutionary in a broad spectrum of fields, and the iPhone wouldn't be possible without the innovation required by NASA and the Apollo program. [1] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/411/what-are-the-everyday-technologies-that-are-a-byproduct-of-the-apollo-program http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/411/what-are-the-ev...
- maxerickson 10y agoIt doesn't exactly take a giant leap of imagination to stick a battery onto a DC motor. How many of those attributions were simply things that Apollo brought forward months or years and how many wouldn't have happened without Apollo?
- kobeya 10y agoAs someone who once worked at NASA, I would take everything said by the spinoff office with a huge grain of salt. They count anything and everything even the most peripherally related to a NASA contract. EDIT: The spinoff office is a clever workaround for government regulations that prevent agencies from doing PR to voters, but it is essentially just that. "Support NASA because we make the economy grow." The problem is that as a PR / propaganda organization, the spinoff office really has absolutely no accountability for what they claim. NASA Watch, an unaffiliated news service and watchdog organization, routinely asks for clarification on many of these spinoffs which NASA is unable to justify. To give you an example of how this plays out, NASA-Ames bought a D-Wave machine. They don't really use it for anything, just a couple of researchers that found money in a budget for a toy, really. Nominally they are evaluating it to see if any NASA applications might benefit from using it. If D-Wave ever amounts to anything, or if it totally fails but some other quantum computer takes off I have no doubt that the spinoff office of 2027 will be claiming that "NASA's early investment in quantum computing technology helped birth the $X billion dollar quantum computing industry," if they haven't already.
- btilly 10y agoAre we talking about the same Apollo space program that brought us satellites? Do you appreciate weather forecasts, satellite TV and improved trans-oceanic telecommunications? That "supercomputer in your pocket" wouldn't be able to give directions if it didn't know where it was, and for that you can thank GPS satellites. We have honestly not followed through in space the way that many of us would like. But our space programs have changed our world. For the better.