3 ms·
It's extremely difficult to know who's account to trust. But it seems likely that both sides made missteps. Committing him is ludicrous. To me, it sounds lik
by wyldfire 10y ago
It's extremely difficult to know who's account to trust. But it seems likely that both sides made missteps. Committing him is ludicrous. To me, it sounds like German may have set off this bitter battle and while he might not have mental health problems, he doesn't sound like a net positive team member.
- apathy 10y agoApparently the judge did not see that as a reason to prevent him from finishing his work and delivering evidence one way or the other (maybe he's awesome and his work will show this, maybe he sucks and his work will show this). "Team science" is actively penalized, just so you know. You're either a rock star PI with 5 R01s and an indentured servant "research professor" to handle actual work, or you're nobody. It is, and always has been, all about the money -- those sweet, sweet indirects from NIH grants, and the endowments from gullible old rich people. Rubin sounds like an asshole, exactly the sort of PI that is selected for at many top-tier institutions. If he's really clever he'll "help" German GTFO of his lab and then write some coded instructions in recommendation letters ("if you've any questions, please call me at 617-867-5309"). And then things can go back to normal, hopefully with Rubin being more cautious and/or less vindictive the next time around.
- yardie 10y agoIf net positive team member means go along to get along then you are right. He had questions about the integrity of the research data and reported that to the ethics board. For this his PI and team members branded him as crazy, going so far as to get him committed. If you suspect someone is tampering with your research you review the access logs or, better yet, put a camera on it. You don't spread a rumor that so and so is crazy and watch your coffee mugs because you don't know what crazy they might do. I believe the judge made the correct ruling. It's unfortunate for the lab and researchers that care caught in the middle.