7 ms·
Oh, hey, will you look at that. The imperfect, incomplete, beta, level 2 self driving cars that were supposed to be the "dangerous" area of self driving are AL
by stale2002 10y ago
Oh, hey, will you look at that.
The imperfect, incomplete, beta, level 2 self driving cars that were supposed to be the "dangerous" area of self driving are ALREADY better than human drivers.
Can we stop the politics and deploy all the real self driving cars to the road immediately, since the government has proven that even the shitty variety is safer than humans?
- Shivetya 10y agoI think the primary issue many of us have is the name. the name implies far more capability than the system delivers. I have seen clear day demonstrations but am eagerly awaiting Tesla to show us a night time rainy video which I have seen references of testing having been done
- extrapickles 10y agoHere is video of the automatic breaking feature triggering at night during light rain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9X-5fKzmy38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9X-5fKzmy38 The name is good for technical people, not so much for lay people who don't know that autopilots are more like cruse controls than something that completely flies the plane (they have been getting better though). The 40% reduction in air-bag activation seems to indicate the name is good enough while its probably not optimal.
- hsod 10y agoAutopilot on planes still requires there to be human pilots for edge cases. I think everyone understands this, because everyone knows that there are still pilots on planes.
- kolbe 10y agoon the other hand, i am easily 3 times safer than the average driver, so self driving vehicles would endanger me.
- robotresearcher 10y agoEven if that was true, the fact that all the other idiots are in self driving cars that are not crashing into you makes you safer.
- maxerickson 10y agoNot necessarily, making other drivers safer makes them less likely to collide with you. Depending on how all the numbers would work out, making other drivers safer could well make you safer too. It might not, but it could.
- martin_bech 10y agoAll the bad drivers would be 40% less likely to crash into you. And since your are a 3x Driver, the only you risk you have while driving, are all the bad drivers.
- pavlov 10y agoDunning-Kruger effect on display?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kolbe 10y agomaybe by you and your command of being able to judge commenters on hacker news.
- belltaco 10y agoOr perhaps it will make you 40% more safe than you already are?
- stuckagain 10y agoThat conclusion is not supported by the data in the report. A supportable conclusion based on this report would be that Tesla automation with auto-steer produces 40% fewer air bag deployments than Tesla automation without auto-steer.
- stale2002 10y agoThats like saying "This medical procedure doesn't save lives, it just results in 40% fewer incidents of sudden heart failure".
- notahacker 10y agoOr saying "just because this drug cocktail appears to reduce incidents of heart failure relative to the weaker drug for patients with a specific condition doesn't mean we should scream at regulators to abandon all further attempts at regulation and start selling all potent heart-related drugs under development over the counter"
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoYou should really read the report. It's comparing Tesla TACC to Tesla TACC+Autosteer. Aka the safety increase when going from Level1 to Level2. It doesn't have anything to do with being safer than human drivers.
- fmihaila 10y agoI think it is reasonable to assume that Tesla TACC is not less safe than Tesla non-TACC, therefore the conclusion is also relevant to comparisons between Tesla level 0 (entirely human-driven, no assist) vs. Tesla level 2.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoWhy would it be reasonable to assume that?
- maxerickson 10y agoI would guess emergency braking is the big difference. The only real stopper there is cost, there are multiple different implementations in vehicles on the road right now.
- mikeash 10y agoLevel 3 is the real danger area. That's the level where the driver is able to do other things, but must be prepared to retake control at any time. Those two ideas are basically contradictory: if you're not already involved with driving, it takes too long to get back into it to do anything useful. Tesla's system is level 2, meaning that the driver must (as in, is supposed to) remain engaged and aware of the driving task at all times, although the car will handle common cases on its own. I believe the plan for everybody is to go straight from level 2 to level 4, since it looks like level 3 is just not going to work. In any case, we can't stop the politics and deploy all the real self driving cars to the road immediately, because there aren't any real self driving cars to deploy yet. The technology is advancing extremely quickly and it's getting close, but politics is not the only obstacle. If and when we have a real, production-worthy self-driving system that's being blocked by politics for no good reason, we can revisit this. I get the sense that, at least in most places, the politics will be pretty easy once the technology gets there. Getting a lot fewer registered voters killed has a way of swaying legislators. Especially in the US, where it's a state-by-state decision, a few states will want to get a jump on it and then the rest will face immense pressure to follow.
- Retric 10y agoMaintaining safety is easier than navigation when you need to deal with all situations. Consider parking in an open field or responding to a traffic cop redirecting traffic. A car may simply stop and require a driver to respond in such situations with any real safety risks.
- Pxtl 10y agoThere is zero chance I'd stay awake behind the wheel of a level 2 or 3 vehicle.
- r00fus 10y agoYou need audiobooks or podcasts. Heck, I love taking a conference call while on my commute (handsfree of course) - 80% of it is in the left lane of an interstate.
- notahacker 10y agoThe "shitty variety" that doesn't have to deal with all the stuff the current state-of-the-art pure self-driving cars don't actually do yet like drive in imperfect road conditions and adapt to unusual circumstances because it's just a braking assistant and cruise control system with humans behind the wheel?
- robotjosh 10y agoThe real safety payoff will be when manual driving is banned on public roads. We will have to fight the "freedom is doing whatever I want" people who are going to defend the right to manually drive on public roads.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoOr just the not-rich people who have old, not-autodriving cars? First-world problems I guess.
- robotjosh 10y agoThe non-rich will adopt self driving cars faster than anyone. They will use these cars as a service and not need to own one or pay for insurance. It will be rich people with their sports cars and fancy motorcycles fighting us on this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]