3 ms·
It's really frustrating the way these huge bills get created. You might have 20% good ideas, 20% toss-outs to the PACs that elected you, 20% earmarks, 20% total
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
It's really frustrating the way these huge bills get created. You might have 20% good ideas, 20% toss-outs to the PACs that elected you, 20% earmarks, 20% total crap, and 20% unknown.
Is a bill like that worth voting for? You can pitch it as solving a huge problem, being an indication of rampant corruption, making progress in a key social or political movement, being a vehicle for bringing money to your state, or being a terrible mistake. Fact is, it could be all of these. Then congressmen can use legislative tricks to both vote for and against the same bill, effectively rendering any kind of simple debate meaningless. Which is the exact reason why it's constructed the way it is.
I think in terms of startups, this is the worst bill I've seen in years. And while I'm sure professional Angel organizations are all on top of the changes and such, we need to be moving in the exact opposite direction than this bill is taking us. I think real reform is needed, but I am deeply worried that the underlying theory here -- that market risk can be managed by committee or legislation -- is deeply flawed. Adding to that structural problem I have is all of these other really bad tack-ons, like giving the FDA more control over the vitamin and supplement business.
Bad. Bad. Bad.
- hga 17y ago"Is a bill like that worth voting for?" Going by the doctor's principle of "First do no harm", no. And your point about corruption is well taken. This bill gives so much discretion to the regulatory bodies in definitions that it's a sure path to a lot more crony capitalism. Us small startup mammals won't fare well in such an environment. The fact that as of now Fannie and Freddie do not come under it's preview should tell us enough....
- jacoblyles 17y agoThe only part of your post that I disagree with is that the bill has 20% good ideas. If the federal government really wanted to discourage excessive risk-taking in the financial marketplace, why doesn't it allow people who make bad bets to lose money? The market offers free financial "regulation" called "losses". Instead, the feds bailed out bondholders of large financial institutions at a rate of 100 cents on the dollar. They bailed out counterparties who took out insurance contracts from insolvent firms. They bailed out the unions that killed the very companies they worked for. They gave $billions in handouts to homeowners who bought a house that they couldn't afford. And what happens to the prudent people who didn't make bad bets? They get to pay taxes to bail out the imprudent people. Thrift is punished and recklessness is rewarded. Then after the fact the feds pass some anti-capitalist bill that they can trumpet in the press that does more harm than good. The feds micromanage the economy in an attempt to prevent the effects of the incentives created by their own past actions. It's all highly irrational.
- hga 17y agoIt's very rational for the politicians ladling out the money ... until they "run out of other people's money", to paraphrase Margret Thatcher.
- Gormo 17y agoThe Confederate constitution was mostly a verbatim copy of the US constitution, but there were a few significant changes made during its adoption. One of them was the addition of this provision to Article I: "Every law, or resolution having the force of law, shall relate to but one subject, and that shall be expressed in the title." Despite its association with the Confederacy, this would be great amendment to the US Constitution.