2 ms·
> Games are quite passive in the grand scheme of things and do little to actually challenge cognition. 1. Sure they do, although I admit it depends on the game
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
> Games are quite passive in the grand scheme of things and do little to actually challenge cognition.
1. Sure they do, although I admit it depends on the game. I'd say video games are more mentally challenging than school, most of the time. I remember most of grade school being kind of a walkover, whereas the games I played were much more consistently challenging, especially when against other people.
2. If what you say is true, why does the research show cognitive improvements from some types of games?
> Compared to other basic toys / learning devices, video games don't have compelling research
What research they do have has shown improvements, though (did you not even read the pdf this thread is based on?). You're not even attempting to refute this, instead you're just ignoring it. Why?
> There's no 3 dimensional space to work through (Legos), no emotional play (dolls, action figures), visual imagination time (crayons, Play Doh)...on and on and on with better examples that don't need batteries and are more stimulating than being a button mashing monkey.
It sounds like you're just not very experienced with video games. I'd take competitive Starcraft as a beneficial cognitive toy over Legos any day of the week.
- maccard 10y ago> I'd take competitive Starcraft as a beneficial cognitive toy over lego any day of the week. What 8 year olds do you know that are playing competitive Starcraft?
- TulliusCicero 10y agoOnes in Korea? ;) Well, my son will probably be one in a few years. He's five now and just picked up Portal 2.