10 ms·
I once designed myself a system for teaching math online. In addition to using an engine like what they're showing here, my plan was to start from more-or-less
by jerf 10y ago
I once designed myself a system for teaching math online. In addition to using an engine like what they're showing here, my plan was to start from more-or-less the beginning, but also track and categorize the errors a given student makes over time. Errors are not generally made randomly, there's a pattern to them.
Then, we could allow the student to "solve" an equation the way they really should, by skipping over two or three steps at a time, but when we see them do something wrong, we can use our table of "errors the student is most likely to make" to explore the space of possible errors between step 4 and step 5, and give focused feedback about what they did wrong. Using that table there's really only a couple hundred possibilities; if that fails we can always ask the student themselves to break it down more tightly. Presumably if someone were making a business out of this, there would be someone on the lookout for errors the computer can't figure out to add what rules they can to the system. (Though there will always be an irreducible residue of incomprehensible error.)
Teaching a student math would then be about reducing each of these errors to zero over time. You'd have the computer custom create problems that hold a constant probability of the student making an error at some point during solving it; say 20% or so. Then as the student demonstrates mastery, you naturally make the problems more complex as you have to put in more steps to make the probability of error go that high.
Instead of a klunky, chunky "ok now we learn this and you blindly practice it, now you learn this and you blindly practice it, and we hope at the end you've learned everything we taught", you would in theory get a naturally progressive, customized difficulty curve that keeps the student continuously engaged with being about 80% correct, but always progressing forward. This approach also naturally ensures that just because we're covering the quadratic equation this week does not mean you get to forget fractions; once you've seen the simple stuff with integers, we're naturally going to fold fractions back in to the problems, for instance.
There's some elaborations on the theme after that, such as pre-examining the generated problems to ensure that the most likely mistakes are all distinguishable by producing different error output.
But I don't have time to do this. I'm at least reasonably confident it would work, though.
- nooron 10y agoDiagknowstics is working on this in Ann Arbor. Not sure how far along they are, but it's a very bright team.
- jerf 10y agoInteresting. I'm literally 15 minutes' walk from them right now. I wish them well; I'd love to have something like this for my own kids in the 3-4 years it'll take for it to be useful for them.
- Pulcinella 10y agoAs a teacher I would kill for something like this, even if it's entirely paper-based instead of digitized. As you said, creating something like this is incredibly time intensive. There is a reason lots of free and paid teaching resources are basically worksheets, a textbook, and an answer key for "documentation." Anything more complicated is so much work. Even if you knew exactly what you wanted to do and how you wanted to implement it, you still have "beta test" it with students, determine the space of possible errors and misconceptions[1], make corrections, etc. I've thought about creating something like this for science, but I "only" teach the same lesson 4-5 times a day. Anything I learn, any corrections I want to make have to wait until next year when I teach that lesson again. Then if those changes don't work or I realize I need to take different changes, I have to wait another year to make them. Not exactly rapid iteration. [1]Not quite as easy as you might think. Students usually can't explain their misunderstanding very well or at all and you probably understand the material too well and it's hard to understand how to solve the problem any way but the correct way.