4 ms·
Edge demands attention till you disable it's popups. Telemetry reactivates itself every time Windows updates. Also Edge forgets your ignore preference, and rep
by shakna 10y ago
Edge demands attention till you disable it's popups.
Telemetry reactivates itself every time Windows updates. Also Edge forgets your ignore preference, and repins itself to the taskbar.
Ads can appear on the start menu, and lock screen.
Office asks to be activated every time you open it if you don't link an email. (Though it is activated).
You no longer have search without Cortana.
These are not small annoyances that happen sometimes. They happen frequently. Microsoft is dictating how you must use a computer.
It results in a lot of calls from less tech savvy friends wanting me to 'fix' their computers.
This seems to me, to be an unsustainable bad business practice. It could work if there was no competition in the market, but Apple certainly competes, and for many, Android is also an option.
That's ignoring the crapshow that tried to force everyone to adopt W10.
- norea-armozel 10y agoOddly, this has yet to happen to me. But I'm still thinking about reverting to Windows 7 if Vulkan adoption continues to take off (and most of my games still use dx9) because the only reason why I updated to Windows 10 was for dx12. So I feel I get no value out of it since I don't play games that ever use it.
- dogma1138 10y agoVulkan Next is likely to mandate windows 10 at least partially for mGPU support and other things wddm2 is brilliant. There might be ways around it but I would not bet my life one it. Windows 10 has also quite a few other advantages like native nvme support, multipath smb and many other neat features. I would also not hold my breath for Vulkan adoption Xbox and PS4 aren't going to support it which means that still most games would use DX on windows.
- valarauca1 10y agoI feel I should point out you can't hold up MacOS/OSX as an alternative to Win10 to avoid A company telling you how to use a computer. That is very much Apple's ballgame. If you don't want an opinionated OS you are going to end up using Linux. Yet commenters will still jump down my throat b/c a single distro does something they dislike.
- shakna 10y agoIn some ways, yes. However, OSX: * Accepts I don't want Safari as my default browser * Will let me disable Siri without breaking core functionality * Doesn't inject adverts into my GUI * Will let me turn off telemetry
- RealCasually 10y agoIn my experience, macOS has similar tricks. I got notifications for "Discover Safari!" even though Chrome was my default browser. Similarly, I got repeated prompts to upgrade to Sierra, which is just as much an "ad" as what you describe.
- WayneBro 10y agoTry avoiding Apples App Store. You can't do it. They integrated with the OS updates. So every time you open it you have to see ads. At least with Wndows I can turn all of the crap off (and I have). I have zero problems with Windows because I configured it the way that I want. Isn't that the same thing you do with any OS? If I don't like something I turn it off or replace it with a third-party tool. Big deal. Do you know how much time I have spent on my Mac and Linux boxes to configure them the way that I want? Way, way more time than I ever spent on Windows.
- shakna 10y agoI do turn it off. Updates turn it back on. That is precisely the big deal. Because many people can't fix it when that happens. So they'll either infect their PC looking for a solution, or be told what they need, and how to do it. By the way, updates are also linked to the Windows Store.
- WayneBro 10y agoTurn what off? Be more specific please. Telemetry? You can set it to basic unless you are on Windows Enterprise. If you are trying to do anything else you are doing it wrong.
- ldev 10y agoHow do I enable ads on start and lock screen? A lot of people are talking about it, I feel left out. :/ >You no longer have search without Cortana. Could you elaborate? search for what? >These are not small annoyances that happen sometimes. They happen frequently. Microsoft is dictating how you must use a computer. Good, otherwise we'd end up with bazillion window managers that get you 80% of "stuff" in bazillion different ways, but none do the other 20%.
- shakna 10y agoAds appeared for me after a month of usage. I assume there's some A/B stuff, and usage indicators used to determine when this should happen. If you disable Cortana, a feat in itself, the file system search functions die. Your last point is not really upheld. Greater flexibility existed in previous versions of Windows. Though different solutions to the inbuilts existed, they weren't popular. However, dictating which browser, through inconvenience, is harmful to the web. IE6 stands to that memory. Forcing telemetry down users throats, so you can better predict them, is spying. It won't result in products for user needs, it'll result in making users think they need less.
- ldev 10y agoExcept for telemetry - I think after using Linux, Windows is confusing to you, because I don't have Cortana and still can search for files, don't see ads. Understandable, as Windows is not *nix, you should just RTFM.
- WayneBro 10y agoTurn it all off then. It took me about 20 minutes of configuring Windows to turn off every single thing you mentioned. You do have search without Cortana. You are incorrect. I use it every day. Stop spreading false information. Honestly, I would hate my Mac and Linux boxes too if I had no clue how to configure them the way that I want. Perhaps you should learn how to configure things properly. Then you can stop complaining.
- shakna 10y agoIt takes me less. But after every update, it's back. How would you feel if every security update wiped your crontab? To revert to legacy search functionality, you need to disable search indexing as well as Cortana's services and regkeys. So, possible, if difficult. Sorry I got it wrong. Neither OSX nor any Linux distro I've used intentially bypasses my config by reactivating disabled services, or modifying my rc files any time I update.
- WayneBro 10y agoSounds like you did something wrong. All the things I configured did not come back. Maybe you should just learn how to do it properly.
- shakna 10y agoFirst, stating that others are doing wrong, is kinda a dick move. You're screwing over a large proportion of users who can't configure, even if it's in control panel. Ignoring them, is just bad practice. Secondly, if there is such a great way of configuring things, where is it documented? SysV, systemd, cron, and every other utility that arrives with a Linux distro has some decent documentation. Apple hosts their own as well. Where is Microsoft's guide to permanently disabling Cortana?
- WayneBro 10y ago> First, stating that others are doing wrong, is kinda a dick move. Oh give me a break. It does sound like you did something wrong. And that's exactly what I said: "Sounds like you did something wrong". Stop taking offense at things that are not offensive. I'd love to see users that can't figure out the control panel try to use Linux. I'd also pay to see them try to do anything on their Mac that Apple didn't want to let them do. Haha good one.
- elipsey 10y agoI haven't seen these issues on a W10 machine yet, but I haven't used it much or on many machines. Maybe I haven't tried the right version/patch level. FWIW I'm writing this on: W10 Pro x64 Version 10.0.14393. --No Edge popups. --File Indexing svc. is off. --Cortana doesn't appear unsolicited in any way I have noticed; when I type w/ start menu open, I get launchable executables that match my search text, just like W7. --I don't see any adds. --UI Config hasn't noticeably change by itself. It would be nice to know more about versions and patch states that are affected. Sounds like maybe some of this stuff is either testing, version dependent, or not fully rolled out?