7 ms·
State's bad teachers rarely get fired
- rmorrison 17y agoIf you want to see an interesting perspective on education in America, I highly recommend watching Bill Gate's TED talk (start at the 8 minute mark): http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/bill_gates_unplugged.html http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/bill_gates_unplugged.html In summary, currently teachers are not held accountable for the quality of their teaching due to the way their contracts are structured. Also, formulas for teacher's pay reward experience and extra education, even though both have been shown to be unrelated to teaching quality. Simply throwing more money at the problem will not help, we need to rethink the current system.
- megablast 17y agoDifficult for the situation to change, if your unions are anything like ours in Australia. In NSW, they recently introduced a website that displays the score of standardized tests, not at the student level but at the school level. There wass a huge uproar by teachers, suddenly everyone can see how well they do, they and their schools can be examined. Due to this, they have come very close to striking at times, lots of complaints about not being able to teach properly, at having to "teach to the tests". There is some truth to this, but it is also a way out for the bad teachers. There needs to be some mechanism for recognising and removing bad teachers. The system is setup at the moment almost as a teacher retirement plan, once you get in, you can't get out.
- uuilly 17y agoLooks like he's also in an upcoming documentary about the broken US public school system: http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/paramount_vantage/waitingforsuperman/ http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/paramount_vantage/waiting... Some of those scenes are from the lottery to get into the DC voucher program. DC is my hometown and the public schools are Cuisinarts for kids. Recently all future funding for the DC voucher program was pulled.
- sgk284 17y agoOur startup (based in Seattle) was looking at ways to help analyze the performance of teachers. It turns out that the unions lobbied for legislation in Washington that forbids such software from being installed in the schools. The unions don't want mediocre teachers to be found out. It's really a crappy situation and really took us by surprise.
- gregwebs 17y agoI think more than just "being found out" unions also have to tell there members that they are doing something for them. Teaching jobs are already really good (except perhaps for the pay, but that is constrained by government budget). So the unions can tell their members that they will always go to bat for them, even though it is almost completely unnecessary for a competent teacher.
- patio11 17y agoIf the unions didn't zealously represent mediocre members, there wouldn't be any point to having them. (There might have been decades ago when management quite literally hired private armies to beat down their employees. Taking a look at the private sector, we can see that non-unionized employees are largely not beaten down by private armies and also don't come to class falling down drunk. Unions have and will continue to zealously defend teachers who do that.)
- philwelch 17y agoThat was my dad's conclusion decades ago, funny enough. Before he joined the Marines towards the end of WWII he was a laborer and union member, and as far as he could tell the union offered virtually no benefit to young and talented workers. Mediocre workers who were loyal to the union long enough to gain seniority did well, but ability got you nowhere. In the wartime Marine Corps he wasn't promoted quickly but he was still given the duties and responsibilities he was capable of as soon as he proved himself. The private armies and so forth were mostly a 19th century phenomenon.
- cabalamat 17y ago
- anigbrowl 17y agoPeople interested in this subject will probably like this forthcoming documentary: http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117941947.html?categoryId=2471&cs=1 http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117941947.html?categoryId=2...
- jbellis 17y agoI bet if I googled hard enough I could find one of these articles for every state in the union.
- wyclif 17y agoIf you do, make a list of the links, turn it into a blog post, and post it here-- I'd upvote it.
- philwelch 17y agoMore generally: Underperforming, unionized civil servants rarely get fired.
- ericd 17y agoSee also: MTA (Transit) in NYC. I frequently see one MTA employee doing work and 4 watching/talking.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ryanhuff 17y agoIts in vogue to bash the teachers these days. In California, the teachers unions have been more prominent in recent years in state-wide political debates, and that seems to have had an impact on public opinion, which is unfortunate. Regarding Bill Gates TED-talk, he compares US and Asia test scores. I don't see how having cheerleader style teachers can mitigate the challenges that many children from under-performing areas are faced with nationwide. These under-performing schools are often in poor areas, where the family educational expectations are low, and the home-life is not conducive to educational success. If US society placed as much emphasis on education as do Japan and other Asian countries, US performance would be much improved. Bill Gates' proposals are a band-aid over the more significant issue.
- anamax 17y ago> Its in vogue to bash the teachers these days. The popularity or lack thereof of something doesn't tell us whether it is wrong. > In California, the teachers unions have been more prominent in recent years in state-wide political debates, and that seems to have had an impact on public opinion, which is unfortunate. How so? Feel free to explain how CA's teachers unions have been a net positive for society over then past 10 years.
- ktsmith 17y agoI can't speak to CA, but in NV much of what the teachers union has done within the school district simply can't be talked about due to confidentiality clauses and other employee protection laws/regulations not to mention those about protecting the identity and privacy of minors. I can tell you that if it weren't for the legal protection offered by the union many good teachers would be out of jobs, and many others would never have become teachers as these services are often not affordable on an individual basis.
- anamax 17y ago> I can't speak to CA, but in NV much of what the teachers union has done within the school district simply can't be talked about due to confidentiality clauses and other employee protection laws/regulations not to mention those about protecting the identity and privacy of minors. That may be (or not), but we're talking about political activity in the open, which has little/no relationship with protecting teachers against administrative sanctions wrt false accusations of child abuse. "Administrative sanctions" is key - criminal accusations ARE public. > I can tell you that if it weren't for the legal protection offered by the union many good teachers would be out of jobs, and many others would never have become teachers as these services are often not affordable on an individual basis. Interestingly enough, teachers aren't the only people accused of such activities. And when other people are so accused, it's public.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoUnions are fine, monopolies are not. When the government grants monopoly licensing powers to a union they are virtually guaranteeing corruption, high prices, and methodological stagnation.
- adamc 17y agoIs this unique to teachers or just a specific instance of a general issue -- that poor employees are seldom fired?
- amock 17y agoThis isn't unique to teachers, it's a problem with unions.
- ryanwaggoner 17y ago"This American Life" had a great segment awhile back on the Rubber Room, which is this room in the NYC school system where teachers who are under investigation or something get stuck. They report there instead of their classrooms, and some of these teachers have been stuck there for years because they can't be fired. Pretty incredible. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/350/Human-Resources http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/350/H...
- thribbler 17y agoPaying people to leave actually sounds like quite a good idea to me. Pay people 3 months salary to leave; don't pay new employees for the first 3 months. It's much easier to identify an underperforming existing employee than to pick the best potential employee at interview. Not paying newbies filters out people who aren't motivated.
- ktsmith 17y agoYou would get few applicants for teaching positions with no pay to start. Teachers have to have degrees and teaching certificates which can be very expensive and given the current state of education many teachers enter the profession with student loans to pay off. An additional problem is that it's becoming increasingly difficult to gain employment as a teacher due to funding cuts and fewer teachers retiring among other factors. A result of this is that it looks like having a masters degree will end up being a requirement for teachers to keep their jobs, or to enter the profession. Being that teachers pay is not comparable to other professions with similar education requirements I don't see how this could possibly help.