3 ms·
"[1] I can't find drinking-by-income data, but anecdotally" Wow, your "non-reference reference" is a brilliant way to criticize that my comment was not based o
by edblarney 10y ago
"[1] I can't find drinking-by-income data, but anecdotally"
Wow, your "non-reference reference" is a brilliant way to criticize that my comment was not based on factual reference!
I didn't say that 'drinking and smoking' is only a problem in 'poor neighbourhoods'. So your comment is not relevant.
In fact, I didn't even refer to 'poor neighbourhoods', I indicated 'Aboriginal communities' in particular - where the problems are systematic and acute.
What is 'laughable' is that anyone would consider that the total social break-down in Aboriginal communities - and the issues that some kids in wealthy areas are remotely related, or should be treated the same way.
In Scandinavian countries, as I mentioned, there is no 'taboo' about drinking. It's 'not positive' but nevertheless 'socially acceptable' to be a kid, drinking every so often. A 'drunk 14 year old' is nothing to make a huge fuss about. Of course, 'a community of drunk 14 year olds' is.
In America - there would indeed be much fuss over a single incidence of fairly underage drinking. It's not socially accepted.
There are basically zero middle or upper class areas in America wherein 42% of 14-16 year year olds have been 'drunk in the last month' and also none where 25% of 14-16 year olds are smoking.
In America overall, the data (which was trivial to find) has it at about 5% [1] (using average of 8th grade and 10th grade).
As it would stand America already has lower teen drunkenness than Iceland even after Icelands 'amazing social program'.
Iceland before: 41%, after: 7%. America now: 5%.
Whoops!
Also - smoking is definitely a much greater issue among lower economic classes, this is consistent in most advanced countries. Drinking - it's a mixed bag. College kids drink the most of any group.
[1] https://responsibility.org/get-the-facts/research/statistics/underage-drinking-statistics/ https://responsibility.org/get-the-facts/research/statistics...
- mundo 10y ago> As it would stand America already has lower teen drunkenness than Iceland even after Icelands 'amazing social program'. Whoops! That would be a real zinger if I had said it wasn't. Look, I'm not sure what you're on about, but it doesn't seem to be related to my comment. Could you go find someone who disagrees with whatever-it-is you think about Aboriginal communities and argue with them?