4 ms·
So what's the difference between that guy and the Onion? Both make money selling fake news, as do the tabloids.
by Clubber 10y ago
So what's the difference between that guy and the Onion? Both make money selling fake news, as do the tabloids.
- sbuttgereit 10y agoThe Onion doesn't try to be perceived as real: it's satire. He wanted you to believe his story was true. One is a joke, the other is fraud.
- Clubber 10y agoDid you really believe there was a warehouse full of Clinton ballots? Do you think everyone knows the Onion is satire?
- sbuttgereit 10y agoThose questions are irrelevant to your first question. You asked what is the difference between the guy in the story and the Onion. That answer doesn't depend on people being cautious or rational about what they chose to believe. It only depends on the intent of the writers. In one case, you have the intent of humor, not at all immoral by itself, though perhaps tasteless from time to time. The other case you have the intent to deceive, to fake reality with the goal of changing people actions: deeply immoral. And for the record: I never heard the Clinton story before this... I find most the news is written for emotional engagement and actually doesn't help to inform me in any important way, so why stress myself out with it? I read very little news... haven't watched a local news broadcast in decades. The recent election was the perfect display of this deficiency. For the Onion, there are documented instances of people taking it seriously... but what can I say? There are documented instances of people doing and believing just about everything. I don't bother with them anymore than I do with "the news".
- Clubber 10y ago>The other case you have the intent to deceive, to fake reality with the goal of changing people actions: deeply immoral. Here's a blurb. Real news, tabloid, Onion, or fake news? >Roger Stone — the D.C. insider who's exposed some of Washington's deepest secrets — was targeted for assassination! That's the shocking claim by the popular author and consultant to Donald Trump, who says that even the Center for Disease Control determined that he was poisoned! He's now gone public with his story of feeling stricken with a “routine stomach virus” in Dec. 2016 — before suddenly becoming exceedingly ill.” I guess the point I'm trying to make is this fake news phenomenon is nothing new. The only difference is one guy was able to make such a large splash.
- raisedbyninjas 10y agoSince the purpose of satire is to criticize or ridicule ideas. When people don't recognize satire, the writers have failed in their job. The only people I see labeling this site as satire are backsplaining after it was exposed. According to the article, even the creator doesn't claim that. I think satire falls into that group of endeavors where when you fail so thoroughly, you're automatically out of the group. An executioner who only non-fatally botches executions is another example.
- matt4077 10y agoIs this an onion-comment? But seriously: intent. To just name one.
- Clubber 10y agoHe said his intent was to make money. Do you not think the Onion has the same intent?
- danso 10y agoIf you're going to be reductive like that, then maybe cop-killers could argue that their intent was realizing "Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness" as stated in the Declaration of Independence. The Onion presents itself as satire [0]; ChristianTimesNewspaper.com didn't. Bill Clinton can't sue The Onion for libel all the times they've made fun of his infidelities. But he could make a case for ChristianTimesNewspaper, which chased pageviews by purporting to be truth. Otherwise, who would visit that site when you can find bucketfuls of blog posts calling Clinton a rapist? [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/blogpost/post/the-onion-tweets-screams-and-gunfire--wheres-the-humor/2011/09/29/gIQASpCI7K_blog.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/blogpost/post/the-onion... > The Onion office in New York confirmed that the tweet was not a hack, saying: “This is satire. That’s how it works.”
- Clubber 10y agoI asked what the difference was. The difference he came up with was intent. The intent was the same: to make money.
- matt4077 10y agoYou're obviously pretending to be dense, but to spell it out: "The onion does not intent to create the appearance of a legitimate news source beyond a superficial resemblance as is necessary for the joke".
- 10y ago
- failrate 10y agoThe Onion is obvious satire. Tabloids are in a weird "entertainment" zone.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aleeds 10y agoThe onion is not spread as if it is truth. The Onion is satire. If you have a hard time telling the difference, I do not think it is their problem.
- Clubber 10y agoThey are both hyperbolic. You know they are both hyperbolic. Most people know they are both hyperbolic. His can certainly be construed as satire. He sure made the people who believed it look foolish, as does the Onion. >If you have a hard time telling the difference, I do not think it is their problem. Perhaps there isn't much difference.
- Retra 10y agoPerhaps your inability to see a difference is a personal problem, not a cultural one.
- Clubber 10y agoI was asking what the difference was because I wanted to have a discussion about hyperbole in the news; what's acceptable, what isn't. I think a lot of news outlets sensationalize the stories through insinuation and salacious headlines. I think that is just as bad as fake news because fake news is easier to spot. Sounds like a lot of people got their feathers ruffled about it. Either they are die hard Onion fans, or they are emotionally married to the argument. It's just politics man, everyone is full of beans. The second you become tribal, you're the sucker.
- Retra 10y agoIf you want to compare fake news to real news, The Onion (which is obviously satire) is not an appropriate comparison to make to start that discussion. You're making a stupid comparison. Of course people will be biased against it.