7 ms·
From Headline to Photograph, a Fake News Masterpiece
- wenbert 10y agoWould google ban ads for fake news sites?
- tlb 10y agoYes. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/15/technology/google-will-ban-websites-that-host-fake-news-from-using-its-ad-service.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/15/technology/google-will-ba...
- tlb 10y agoThe banality of evil, right there. Good work by NYT reporter Scott Shane, who did the legwork and got the confession.
- danso 10y agometa: The submitted title, "How a 23-Year-Old Wrote a Fake News Masterpiece" is the headline as the NYT currently has it formatted for the front page. It's obviously catchier than the article's standalone hed, "From Headline to Photograph, a Fake News Masterpiece", but the fact that this was instigated by a recent college grad is one of the more memorable parts of the article to me. What he did was the kind of cynical play that I would expect from people much older and savvier about how the world works. That said, I think he's a shitty opportunist. Not for his specific politics, but for his actions in general, and his weak attempts to justify them (“Hardly anything a campaign or a candidate says is completely true"). It'll be interesting to see where his aspirations of being a political consultant end up. The article mentions he was exposed by "a reporter who had discovered an electronic clue that revealed his secret authorship of ChristianTimesNewspaper.com". I wonder what that "electronic clue" was? He bought Godaddy's whois privacy protector for that domain.
- tantalor 10y agoIs this legal? Seems like a fraud concocted for the purpose of financial gain. Obviously has no redeeming value like a satire.
- danso 10y agoI think the main example of fake votes found in Ohio would be legal, in the sense that no (real) person's reputation was harmed. But the article about "NYPD Looking to Press Charges Against Bill Clinton for Underage Sex Ring" seems like a strong libel case. In the U.S., public figures (like Bill Clinton) have a higher standard of proof for libel, and they can't sue just because something false was printed about them. But knowingly publishing falsehoods is something that a public figure can sue for.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y agoNot as strong a case for libel as you would think considering the relationship between Clinton and Epstein, who was convicted of soliciting underage girls >The relationship between Clinton and Epstein has been chronicled previously, and flight logs show that the former president flew on the financier's private jet more than ten times in the years before Epstein was accused of having sex with underage girls. >Between 2002 and 2005 Clinton took numerous trips including to Epstein's Caribbean island Little St James where young girls were supposedly kept as sex slaves. Clinton was deemed to be so close to Epstein that he was nearly deposed during the investigation into his pedophilia, legal documents have shown. A phone transcript filed in a lawsuit includes references to 'favors' that Clinton owed Epstein. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3825882/The-cozy-relationship-billionaire-Jeffrey-Epstein-Bill-Clinton-flew-pedophile-s-private-jet-praised-insights-generosity-detailed-new-book-James-Patterson.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3825882/The-cozy-rel... Edit: Downvotes are cute when the facts are not in dispute.
- danso 10y agoBeing deposed to testify in someone else's case is a lot different than having the NYPD looking to press charges against you. The latter implies some very concrete evidence of wrongdoing. But you do have a point. I think the fake news purveyor in this case could argue that Clinton's reputation wasn't measurably harmed, given his already infamous reputation. It's a different impact than if the fake story was about Bernie Sanders or Jeb Bush.
- quickConclusion 10y agoPeople learn. I still believe more in people than algorithms to debunk fake news. This election was step 1 in people's learning curve about it. Of course, if they don't want to learn, they won't. But no algorithm or laws will change that anyway.
- danso 10y ago> Of course, if they don't want to learn, they won't. But no algorithm or laws will change that anyway. Hasn't the recent cycle shown the power of algorithms, whether we recognize their work? If fake news was less back in the "good ol days" of the Internet, it was because Google's PageRank was inherently biased towards sites maintained by organizations with the resources and brand names to have popular sites, e.g. news organizations. If Facebook prioritizes shared stories in your news feed based by how many people shared it, then that makes it much easier for randomnewssite.biz to make it to your eyeballs via FB's ranking and filtering algorithm.
- quickConclusion 10y agoAgree. But my point is that people adapt and learn. They assumed PageRank was still ruling and could be somewhat trusted, and now they're learning -a little late- that FB's popular randomnewssite.biz should be challenged. Maybe something new will happen at the next election, but it will be harder to convince people with this type of fake news.
- danso 10y agoI think you give users too much credit. I don't use Facebook often, but this "Related Articles" caught my eye when it popped up in the newsfeed: http://imgur.com/a/83kzS http://imgur.com/a/83kzS There's no differentiation between the 3 items in terms of visual layout, and the domains of the respective news items are visually deprioritized by Facebook's design. If you don't actually click through to "bigbluevision.org" -- and studies claim that 50-60%+ people just read a headline before sharing/moving on -- the claim that "Obama's Lawyers Official Admit Birth Certificate is Fake" has as much cognitive impression as ABC News's "Obama Calls Conversation With Trump'Excellent'". Seeing a bunch of fake headlines, over time, would seem to have the same effect as watching advertisements. The viewer doesn't have to do anything, but are affected nonetheless.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 10y agoSo what's the difference between that guy and the Onion? Both make money selling fake news, as do the tabloids.
- sbuttgereit 10y agoThe Onion doesn't try to be perceived as real: it's satire. He wanted you to believe his story was true. One is a joke, the other is fraud.
- Clubber 10y agoDid you really believe there was a warehouse full of Clinton ballots? Do you think everyone knows the Onion is satire?
- sbuttgereit 10y agoThose questions are irrelevant to your first question. You asked what is the difference between the guy in the story and the Onion. That answer doesn't depend on people being cautious or rational about what they chose to believe. It only depends on the intent of the writers. In one case, you have the intent of humor, not at all immoral by itself, though perhaps tasteless from time to time. The other case you have the intent to deceive, to fake reality with the goal of changing people actions: deeply immoral. And for the record: I never heard the Clinton story before this... I find most the news is written for emotional engagement and actually doesn't help to inform me in any important way, so why stress myself out with it? I read very little news... haven't watched a local news broadcast in decades. The recent election was the perfect display of this deficiency. For the Onion, there are documented instances of people taking it seriously... but what can I say? There are documented instances of people doing and believing just about everything. I don't bother with them anymore than I do with "the news".
- Clubber 10y ago>The other case you have the intent to deceive, to fake reality with the goal of changing people actions: deeply immoral. Here's a blurb. Real news, tabloid, Onion, or fake news? >Roger Stone — the D.C. insider who's exposed some of Washington's deepest secrets — was targeted for assassination! That's the shocking claim by the popular author and consultant to Donald Trump, who says that even the Center for Disease Control determined that he was poisoned! He's now gone public with his story of feeling stricken with a “routine stomach virus” in Dec. 2016 — before suddenly becoming exceedingly ill.” I guess the point I'm trying to make is this fake news phenomenon is nothing new. The only difference is one guy was able to make such a large splash.
- msravi 10y agoI think the mainstream media is using this to support their own delusions. It is because of the drop in credibility of mainstream media that people have begun believing in unverified sources. It is because of the blatant and obvious bias and hypocrisy in mainstream media that people seek other sources to support their own biases. If the mainstream media were to be more honest and unbiased in their reporting and did not try to massage delivery to suit a narrative, the fake news out there wouldn't have that many takers. As it stands today, people place as much credibility in a CNN or nytimes piece as they do in a whatsapp forward or tweet.
- danso 10y agoThat's a romanticized view of the way the world works, or how people make choices. When music sales started falling precipitously around the rise of the MP3 player, was it because music became measurably worse? When artists started making money from digital downloads, was it because they just started making better music? Or because iTunes/etc vastly improved the digital download purchasing process? Most big cities had morning and afternoon newspapers. Now there are only morning newspapers. Is it because afternoon newspapers just happened to be shittier than their morning competitors in every city in America? Or because the advent of radio and TV news changed the timing of how we get daily news?
- msravi 10y agoNotice that I didn't say "newspaper" or "tv"? It isn't about the medium - mainstream (established) media is as much on social media as other news websites that may or may not be fake. It's the credibility that has been lost and a huge advantage that they had coming in that has been squandered.
- dplgk 10y agoYou might have a point if the sample group here weren't people that watch Fox News. Instead, they are questioning one of the most respected newspapers in the world while still eating up talking points from Rush Limbaugh.
- winteriscoming 10y ago>> That was a sizable share of the $22,000 an accounting statement shows he made during the presidential campaign from ads for shoes, hair gel and web design that Google had placed on his site. Is this for real? That article also claims around $1000 per hour earning with these ads. I had google ads on my blog for years and hardly made anything of note in terms of earning. I understand this is different type of site attracting a different audience, but even then I find it hard to believe people would have clicked those ads (let alone bought anything) to earn him that much. Is this rate of earning common for sites like these?
- vthallam 10y agoI checked the traffic for the mentioned website on Simlarweb and it is around 750,000 in Nov and 650,000 in Oct, so yeah, considering this is all US traffic, if he had put advts in the right places, these earnings are not really difficult to make.
- white-flame 10y ago> He had put in perhaps half an hour a week on the fake news site, he said, for a total of about 20 hours. Taking the numbers literally, that's working over the course of 40 weeks. It doesn't really say how long those revenues lasted for the total of $22k, but given the context I'd assume it's around a year.
- eternalban 10y ago> In a dubious art just coming into its prime, this bogus story would be his masterpiece. New York Times clearly has no respect for its readership. Just coming to its prime? That very Pulitzer prize that they award to each other is named after one of the more famous practitioners of publishing fake stories to sway public opinion. This is not a new dubious art form. It is called propaganda. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_of_the_Spanish%E2%80%93American_War#Hearst_and_Pulitzer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_of_the_Spanish%E2%8...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- losteverything 10y agoI know this to be true. At one job the entire department voted trump. If I went to them and asked them what they thought of fake news, and in particular this specific article "Clinton ballots in Ohio was really a fake including the photo", they would ask "where did you hear that?" If I say the New York Times their answer would be "of course. They hate trump. Why should I believe that story?" If I say it's from hacker news they would not know what HN is and perhaps listen. We are at a point where the "I don't trust any media" is already out of the bag. It's too late to add new trust. They will only keep those that trust them now. Eventually something will gain trust and take over the trust again. It won't be an incumbent.
- keyle 10y agoYeah from an outsider looking in (not in the US), it's really scary. You have people believing fake news because it makes them feel something about themselves, and call real news fake, because it's the easiest way to cover up facts. Social media is a wild fire of BS and "friends" can literally influence each other, every day. It's social hacking with dominoes.
- dplgk 10y agoWhat doesn't make is that they decided to trust Trump. When did the rich New York loud mouth earn their trust?
- losteverything 10y agoWe talked. It was the lesser of 2 evils. The fake news was a side show and not important in their decision. They didn't want a Clinton. Period. Any republican candidate would have had their support - even Donald trump. So fake news fits in perfectly to the malleable mindset theory that without fake news trump would not win. Fake news outing is actually good. Fake news is like glaucoma. It's silent and displays no symptoms. Every reader of any news should assume it's fake until proven useful and true
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- arca_vorago 10y agoAnyone talking about fake news without talking about operation mockingbird hasn't done their homework.
- saywatnow 10y ago> With a quick Google image search for “ballot boxes,” he landed on a shot of a balding fellow standing behind black plastic boxes that helpfully had “Ballot Box” labels. Do ballot boxes actually look like that? Is it a coincidence that the labels are all identically sized, aligned with the picture and perfectly clean/unscuffed .. quite unlike the boxes they're "on"? Curious where the pic came from, in any case.
- saywatnow 10y agoalso, the photo is taken inside the back of a truck. Hence the webbing and blankets. Just how credulous are people?
- Jarwain 10y agoThe article states that he got the photo from the Birmingham Mail. Funnily enough, after this NYT article, the Birmingham Mail released an article about how their own image was used for this fake news article. Even stranger, it looks like someone took this original photo, flipped it, got rid of all of the labels, then created new labels for a few boxes. Probably to make it more difficult for reverse image search to find the original. http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/birmingham-mail-photo-used-fake-12476900 http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/birmingha...