4 ms·
> A friend of mine put it into good words: Go and Rust are two big conclusions, to big follow-ups to the C and C++ world. Go isn't a replacement for C; you can
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> A friend of mine put it into good words: Go and Rust are two big conclusions, to big follow-ups to the C and C++ world.
Go isn't a replacement for C; you can't use it for many forms of low-level systems programming, because it has a runtime. Go provides a high-performance replacement for things you might otherwise write in Python or similar, and in that capacity it works quite well.
Rust can do anything C can; its capabilities build upwards from bare metal, not downwards from higher-level languages. It intentionally doesn't have a runtime, and its approach to avoiding garbage collection (namely borrow checking) provides safe memory handling without a runtime at the expense of being a novel language feature without analogue in other languages. Much of the learning curve in Rust comes from that.
- staticassertion 10y agoI think we like to say things like "C has no GC so it's good for kernels, Python has a GC so it's good for blah blah". In reality, we've definitely written plenty of "python level" (application level) software in C, and the same is happening in Rust.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> In reality, we've definitely written plenty of "python level" (application level) software in C, and the same is happening in Rust. Oh, absolutely; you can certainly write higher-level code in Rust, and it makes for a far more comfortable experience than writing higher-level code in C. I didn't intend to suggest otherwise. And the ongoing futures work helps Rust address several additional areas that Go does well. However, I don't think it makes sense to group Go and C together, syntax aside. Go cannot replace every use of C, because of its runtime and related expectations. (You can push it into some low-level environments if you make accommodations for its runtime, but you can do the same for languages like Python. You wouldn't necessarily want to do so in production, though.)