3 ms·
The complaints about git porcelain are totally understandable. The UI is horrendous. However the internals are elegant and actually much simpler than subversi
by dasil003 17y ago
The complaints about git porcelain are totally understandable. The UI is horrendous. However the internals are elegant and actually much simpler than subversion, so if you understand the internals and do a little rote memorization then suddenly you can manipulate your repository expertly, creating better commits and handling unusual needs with ease. It's the difference between being good with a unix shell and running windows configuration wizards to do everything.
I don't expect the OA to grok that, however one thing that I hope the author takes to heart is this:
With git plumbing it would be fairly straightforward to create a new porcelain VCS combining any balance of elegance, simplicity and power that you desire. With subversion on the other hand, it is almost unimaginable that they would ever be able to correctly track a merge without a hundred bizarre edge cases due to the fact that their repository structure muddles branches and directories.
Why hasn't someone who knows git created a better porcelain yet? Probably because once you know git well enough you don't want to give up any of it's native power just to satisfy some noob's anxiety attack.
- dlsspy 17y ago> Why hasn't someone who knows git created a better porcelain yet? Probably because once you know git well enough you don't want to give up any of it's native power just to satisfy some noob's anxiety attack. They exist. gitx, magit, etc... are all great tools. Most people who use it for any length of time seem to be just fine with it, though. I can recognize a few things as... silly (e.g. checkout), but not so much as to try to introduce a new verb and redefine the semantics just to come up with a better separation when I already know what I'm doing with the tool. I certainly don't have enough of a problem to write an entirely new interface when the existing one continues to get incrementally better. Similarly vi and emacs are both great editors whose power cannot be harnessed by those who don't spend time trying to learn them. The vested are less affected by idiosyncrasies.