3 ms·
Here's a similar graph for the UK (but by total tax paid rather than marginal): http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/UK_tax_NIC_percentages.svg
by petercooper 17y ago
Here's a similar graph for the UK (but by total tax paid rather than marginal):
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/UK_tax_NIC_percentages.svg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/UK_tax_NI... (or if your browser won't do SVG, this is almost the same: http://www.reviewmylife.co.uk/data/2008/0901/percentage-of-income-as-tax-08-09.gif http://www.reviewmylife.co.uk/data/2008/0901/percentage-of-i...)
It's funny that the UK - being European - has a reputation for high taxes and "socialism." There's a lot I don't like about the UK but the taxes are mostly fair (it's the rules for ancillary tax issues that are messed up). The taxes there even include emergency medical expenses.
Mr. Californian earning $50k would be at ~42% on the main post's graph. Mr. Brit earning £34k (roughly equivalent) would be ~26% on the UK graph (or even less if he were self employed!). Hmm.. perhaps sky high gas taxes and 17.5% VAT are a little more bearable for me now.. :-)
[Note: I ballsed up in that last paragraph. The CA chart was marginal, not total like the UK graph. The UK marginal rate at £34k would be 20% for income tax (http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/rates/it.htm http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/rates/it.htm), 11% for NICs. So 31% vs 42%. However, at £35k the marginal rate would be 40% + 11% NIC == 51%. At £40k, however, the marginal rate would be 40% + 1% NIC == 41%. Who said this was easy??]
- eggoa 17y agoThe Californian would be taxed 42% of his 50,000th dollar. Overall I believe he's paying less than 26% of his entire income.
- petercooper 17y agoDoh, good call. I fell into the marginal vs total trap I tried to cover in my first paragraph, lol. I'll add a note.
- gcv 17y agoThat's an interesting comparison, thanks for posting it. I'd love to see something similar for some other countries famous for high taxes and high social services, e.g., Sweden.
- dschobel 17y agoWouldn't fair taxes, strictly speaking, be a horizontal line?
- jrp 17y agoIn the marginal or total revenue? Ie tax = C, or tax = c * income? How would we define fair here? Both of the above options seem somewhat fair: everyone contributes the same amount, or everyone contributes the same percentage of income. Or a third standard for fairness could be that the benefit you get from government programs is equal to what you pay in taxes. I don't even know which of these I think is best (let alone a hope of ever changing anything). Perhaps the best way to cash out "fair" in this case would be to start with some assumptions about what taxes are supposed to do; eg solve coordination problems, support disadvantaged people, etc; and see what can be derived.
- brc 17y agoYou've just described a flat tax rate. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax You can count me into the people who support flat tax rates, if for no other reason to stop the pointless millions of hours of productive time wasted trying to rort the system. While people will always cheat, if all income is taxed at a flat rate, at the source, then the incentive to spend money on tax accountants falls.
- petercooper 17y agoThe Negative Income Tax seems like an interesting flat-tax proposal that could even satisfy those in favor of progressive taxation for political reasons: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax
- jonshea 17y agoSee also the Bradley X Tax, which is a value-added tax melded with an income tax. The income tax can be as progressive as you like, and the VAT is equivalent to a flat sales tax. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_tax http://www.princeton.edu/~ceps/workingpapers/93bradford.pdf http://www.princeton.edu/~ceps/workingpapers/93bradford.pdf
- tomsaffell 17y agoThis comparrison is a little misleading, even now updated for marginal/average rate issue. There are several issues: 1. The 'example' earning of GBP 34k is just below the threshold at which the margin rate switches to 40% (double!) 2. The UK number exlcudes National Insurance payments, whereas the Cali one includes Social Security (the US Equivalent) 3. The UK one does not have Council Tax, but the US one does have State income tax. Whilst council tax is not income based, it does correlate with income, so this the two are more comparable than not. [UPDATE - looks like my reply crossed in the ether with your update :) when will HN get etherpad commenting ? ;]
- petercooper 17y agoYou're right, I fixed many of the issues seemingly at the same time you were writing, sorry! :-) However: Whilst council tax is not income based, it does correlate with income I don't think that's true. I'm a higher rate taxpayer and I'm in band A, the lowest band, whereas most of the people I know with high council tax bills are retired or otherwise coming to the ends of their career (on not much pay). That said, council tax isn't relevant here since American homeowners typically pay property taxes as an equivalent (and property taxes tend to be higher than council tax).
- tomsaffell 17y agoYou're right - property taxes (which I forgot about) probably outweigh council taxes. But regarding the correlation, I find it very hard to believe that within a borough, those with higher income dont on average pay more council tax, no matter your two exceptions ;) (see my other comment)
- petercooper 17y agoIn the South East and London, you're probably right. It's difficult to define, though, with the ways council tax can be divided up on a per-person basis. In my county, I think my argument stands. Only 6% of the population is 25-35 and 40% is 60+. As a rather work poor area, nearly all of the expensive houses are owned by people who no longer work :-) This is life oop North!