4 ms·
While I don't agree with most of your post, I agree with one thing - the EU are, and should (must) make an Example of the UK, or I think the union will fall apa
by alkonaut 10y ago
While I don't agree with most of your post, I agree with one thing - the EU are, and should (must) make an Example of the UK, or I think the union will fall apart after votes in e.g. Italy.
Whether or not the EU should in fact try with any means to keep the union together is another question of course. But; assuming that's their goal, then I consider it pretty reasonable to a) try to rob London of as much financial business as possible by scaring large corporations into moving to EU cities b) scare other countries into not leaving the union by demonstrating a bad deal for the UK c) set tough positions before the Brexit negotiations start (which may be loosened during the actual negotiations).
As a citizen of another EU country, I completely back what the EU is doing centrally at the moment, that is, I care less about the lives and careers of london financial workers, than I do the future integrity of the union. I completely agree with statements like "They voted out and there has to be consequences". Not because it is axiomatically so, but because I think tough consequences are the right choice
- NetStrikeForce 10y ago> I think the union will fall apart after votes in e.g. Italy. What vote exactly?
- alkonaut 10y agoFuture referendums on leaving the EU, in core EU countries. There are more or less advanced plans or propositions in many EU countries although none have yet had a proper referendum (and doing so in a Eurozone country would be more complicated than Brexit)
- tobltobs 10y ago"There are more or less advanced plans or propositions in many EU countries." Citation needed.
- alkonaut 10y agoMarine Le Pen (3rd party leader in France) demands a referendum. A leader of the 3rd party in Germany (Die Linke) demands the same thing. Luckily these countries are among the least likely to leave.
- tobltobs 10y agoMarine Le Pens demands == advanced plans ?
- alkonaut 10y agoIn her party, yes. If they don't get power it's all nothing of course.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoNo offense, but you're a bit deluded and confusing wishes with reality. Also, you didn't answer my question: What vote exactly? You mentioned Italy, so I guess it had something to do with Italy - however you haven't answered.
- alkonaut 10y ago> What vote exactly? I'm talking about future referendums. Those can be held in any European country where either a EU-critical party wins power, or a popular demand calls for it (such calls recently failed in Finland, for example, although a referendum had it been held would never have resulted in an exit). So to be very clear- There are no planned exit referendums, there have been no other such referendums than the Brexit vote, and without petitions or power shifts there are no such votes on the horizon. So by "What votes" I mean e.g a vote under LePen or the next Italian government. Not sure what you think I "wish", I certainly don't hope for any such referendums around Europe.
- NetStrikeForce 10y ago
- muninn_ 10y agoThe grown up thing to do is to try to make things work for both sides.
- sgift 10y agoThe grown up thing is to do what's best for your side. If this also happens to be good for the other side that's okay, but not a priority.
- alkonaut 10y agoThe immature thing to do would be to make things worse for the other side, at no gain to your own side. No one is suggesting anything of the sort.
- dustinmoris 10y agoThis is not true. What if the EU realises that even if both walk away as winners no one will easily follow the UK, because frankly no other EU member state is in a similar position to the UK? There's only 9 member states who didn't adopt the Euro, so basically everyone else already disqualified to leave the EU. When you look at the remaining 9 (Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Poland, Romania, Sweden, and the United Kingdom) there is either no appetite for an exit (Sweden, Denmark) or the country has simply no leverage at all. So would the EU risk to fall apart when the UK gets a good deal? Nope. Remember you heard it first here.
- alkonaut 10y agoIf Austria or Italy had referendums that decided to leave the EU they would do so (And leave the Euro at the same time, obviously). Whether or not it's technically o legally possible to leave doesn't really matter. I don't consider it likely but I also don't consider the current political climate "rational", sadly. The Eurozone is really what should be dismantled, because it's flawed by design. I'd hate to see the union itself which is originally a peace and trade project disintegrate because of a flawed currency and disagreements on people movement.
- dustinmoris 10y agoThe point is not if another country like Austria or Italy would/want to have a referendum. If a country just dislikes the EU and wants to leave then the outcome of the UK/EU deal will not make a difference. What matters though is if another country thinks they can leave the EU with the outlook of a "better" deal outside the EU. The EU would fall apart if countries would believe that, but what I tried to say is that the EU doesn't really have to fear that, because no other country is even remotely in the same position as the UK, so the chances of a "better" deal outside the EU are almost non-existent, because the fact alone that they don't have their own currency would makes significantly more difficult. Therefore the EU can actually work out a good deal for the UK and the EU without jeopardizing the EU membership of others. Makes sense?
- 10y ago
- zigzigzag 10y agoYou see, this sort of thing doesn't make self-proclaimed "European citizens" popular in the UK. The EU should stand or fall on its own merits. The moment people start to think, we have to make it painful for people to leave, it loses its legitimacy. It is on the way to be a new USSR. And if one day continental Europe slowly turns into a military dictatorship (it is effectively already a soft power dictatorship) I will not have any sympathy for whatever happens to people like you.
- alkonaut 10y ago> You see, this sort of thing doesn't make self-proclaimed "European citizens" popular in the UK. I didn't mean that in the sense of being a cosmopolite euro-citizen, I simply meant I'm a resident of an EU country other than the UK. I have no wishes for consequences as punishment alone, I only want consequences in the sense that benefits such as low trade barriers should be shared among those who create them and share the burdens, e.g who accept strict common envirinmental regulations and allow freedom of people to move. Of course countries would prefer the benefits of a collaboration/union/pact/ without the responsibilities and costs.
- zigzigzag 10y agoBut this is my point - the EU is a project to try and force people to accept ideas they think are bad ideas by artificially tying them to cooperation and trade. Instead of letting each idea be individually tested in the marketplace of debate and experimentation, the EU simply insists that if you want A, you have to do B and C regardless of merits. EU leaders like to paint people who reject this approach as shirking their "responsibilities", or "cherry picking", or whatever other dubious analogy they came up with today. But it's just psychological manipulation. If citizens of a country are overwhelmingly convinced that freedom of movement makes sense only for similar economies, or only up to a limit, etc, then it's not the EU's place to blindly insist that they obey. It's the EU's place to convince them they're wrong, if necessary, by letting them go their own way so some years later the results can be compared. That is how you build trust and loyalty. You know, 18 months ago I was vaguely pro EU. Like most people I had not thought about it much, in truth. The UK referendum forced me to do my research, to spend a lot of time pondering the issues, to engage with the eurosceptic arguments. And nowadays I am convinced the EU is doomed. It is a concept so flawed it cannot be fixed. It should be abolished and replaced with numerous multi-lateral treaties between whoever wishes to make them, wherever those countries are located in the world. In other words, how the global system of cooperation already operates. There is no need to artificially tie immigration with financial regulation, or medical approvals with subsidies to farmers. There is no need for a flag, an anthem, an all powerful centralised bureaucracy of people who care more about their pensions than the people they rule. Europe would be happier, healthier and experiencing deeper cooperation if the EU had never been invented at all.