4 ms·
They are demonstrating that they didn't find difference. Not that none exist. They do exist, and this is easy to verify with the Piaget Water Level Task. The
by btilly 10y ago
They are demonstrating that they didn't find difference. Not that none exist. They do exist, and this is easy to verify with the Piaget Water Level Task.
The task is simple. Draw a cup like |_| and then the same tilted perhaps 30 degrees. Hand the pictures to someone and ask, "If they are both half-full of water, draw the water line." Conduct this experiment on 5 random adult friends of each gender.
With extremely high probability, you will now have very strong evidence that there are very real brain sex differences. No demonstrated ones that seem particularly important to me, but clearly they exist.
(I first encountered this as part of a pair of questions, this one and another which women got and men didn't. I thought it was BS, a month later gave this one to my then girlfriend, and have never again found the other. Incidentally there is no difference on performance in this one until puberty. Interestingly the odds of success for gay/trans people are between straights, suggesting that their brains tend to be mixes of "normal" in more ways that one.)
- majewsky 10y agoCan you share the expected results? I don't have 5 random adults with me right now. ;) And Google does not turn up anything useful (only paywalled papers).
- btilly 10y agoAround 90% of men find the task trivial. About 70% of women can't do it. Additionally women who can't do it when presented with the same task years later remember that there is a trick, but have trouble remembering it and still can't do it. I have never met a programmer, male or female, who found the task anything other than trivial. I have no idea why, and no idea whether this fact may be correlated with the gender imbalance in programming.
- tzs 10y agoDid you specify about 30 degrees because the trivial method fails if the tilt is too large? I see a trivial solution, but it only works if the ratio of the water height before tilting to the diameter of the cup is greater than the tangent of the tilt angle.
- tzs 10y agoOK, I've done some reading on this, including a several year old blog entry on this topic by the person who brought it up here [1], and it looks like I misunderstood what is required to consider the problem solved. I took it as requiring that volume, shape, and orientation of the water all be correct in the tilted cup, and assumed that people who fail are probably getting shape and orientation right but are not getting the volume right. Apparently, the failure mode is typically to get the shape and/or orientation wrong, and you pass if you get them right. Volume doesn't have to be right. [1] http://bentilly.blogspot.com/2010/08/piaget-water-level-test.html http://bentilly.blogspot.com/2010/08/piaget-water-level-test...
- btilly 10y agoExactly. The whole challenge is, "Can you remember that water should be horizontal to the horizon?" Remember that, and you pass.