3 ms·
Here's an economics question that I used to think about when I was trading bitcoin: Does volatility of an asset itself create value? It seems like the more vo
by empath75 10y ago
Here's an economics question that I used to think about when I was trading bitcoin:
Does volatility of an asset itself create value? It seems like the more volatile the price is, the more opportunities there are to make big profits trading the swings using a 'reversion to mean' strategy. Which would mean more people trading it, which would mean that over time, the 'mean' price would keep trending upwards, until that volatility reduced to the point where the strategy was no longer profitable.
Does that make any sense at all? I'm sure there's a broken link in that chain of logic somewhere.
- pdovy 10y agoI work in HFT, though we don't deal with Bitcoin. I don't think volatility creates any value, but it can be a sign of market inefficiency if it's caused by a lack of liquidity (demand > supply). A typical market making strategy would be to provide liquidity while betting on mean reversion, which will have the effect of dampening volatility. The price won't necessarily trend in any particular direction, it should just dislocate less from some "true" theoretical value.
- bb88 10y agoVolatility usually is considered bad. Why would you want to invest in something whose day to day price can change 20%? For day-traders and HFT volatility is good, since they can (as you have said) ride the swings. There's the value of a bitcoin, and the value that bitcoin brings to the market. And those are two different things. The value bitcoin brings is anonymous currency transactions and anonymous speculation. Now ask yourself what is the value of one bitcoin? It's not based on a physical scarce resource like coal or oil. It's not based upon an actual currency either (either gold backed or fiat). In fact the only value people have in it is that other people invest in it. So speculation has created value. Volatility in this case is just a side effect of speculation.
- logicchains 10y agoIn some cases volatility is categorically good, e.g. if you have a put option that's in the money. Volatility increases the chance of it either going far into the money (so you profit) or far out of the money (in which case you can just choose not to exercise the option): it increases potential reward without increasing potential loss (you'll never lose more than the premium you paid for the option).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rz2k 10y agoGenerally speaking, liquidity is valuable, and risk is a problem. The volatility might be an indicator of liquidity, or at least attempts to reduce volatility may correspond with reduced liquidity, such as putting your money in a hedge fund that has restrictions on when you're allowed to pull your money back out. On the other hand volatility can provide arbitrage opportunities for people who know what the "true" price would be. A simple theory suggest that there is a trend, zero or more cyclical patterns, and noise. If you can identify what is noise and what is not the trend, then you can trade against those prices. From the perspective of social utility, pricing error is bad for the economy, and the people who correct it get a share of the recovered efficiency in the market. In the case of bitcoin it is difficult for me to imagine how to determine a true value. The supply is predictable compared to money, even though the factors that affect the supply of money aren't as unguessable as sometimes claimed. The demand for bitcoin though seems really difficult to understand. As a result its value is much more likely to resemble a random walk, which would mean that there is no mean for the price will revert to.