4 ms·
> So when the SIP says that the price of a stock is $40.02, Citadel knows that it's really $40.01, so it can buy the stock at $40.01 and sell it to you for $40.
by gpderetta 10y ago
> So when the SIP says that the price of a stock is $40.02, Citadel knows that it's really $40.01, so it can buy the stock at $40.01 and sell it to you for $40.016 for a guaranteed risk-free profit.
This implies that Citadel is buying the stock before selling it to you. I doubt that's the case as waiting for the ack from the exchange before handing the latency would be too high, more likely that Citadel assumes it is likely that it can buy it for that price at the same time that it is selling it to you (and that's seems what's implied in the FastFill description). That's not guaranteed profit as Citadel is taking a risk (albeit small) as its buy at the better price might not be filled.
edit: and in fact the article later says that this risk-free arbitrage is not really risk free.
- hawleyal 10y ago> This implies that Citadel is buying the stock before selling it to you. Large firms do this business as usual. They maintain inventory and sell it to their customers directly, while still reporting the trade to the market audit trail. This is usually done by the private brokerage side of the firm executing all trades through the public investment side, and the investment side just executes the trade against the house inventory instead of a third party buyer/seller in the market.
- gpderetta 10y agoOf course they do, but if they don't get a guaranteed buy on the exchange at the current best price, they can't guarantee profit.
- tom_pei 10y agoYea they are insinuating the process of being the third party and performing arbitrage. They are just taking your money at the price they offer you and fill the order at the cheaper price available to them. They are being the middle man and making money from the spread.
- leakybit 10y agoThat is how it works. When you buy stock, you buy it from market makers, such as Citadel, for the Ask price, and when you sell it, Citadel buys the stock for the bid price. At the moment Google's Ask is $803.39 and Bid is $803.15, so Citadel would make $0.24 off each transaction. Multiply that by avg daily volume, equates to $421,872 in daily profits for market making. I wouldn't be suppressed if Citadel simply sells marginally cheaper just so they get more volume to extract information about price/volume trends before their competitors can
- gpderetta 10y agoJust because the market is showing GOOG ask @803.39, doesn't mean that if you send an order at that price it will be filled. This means that Citadel is not guaranteed the 'risk-free' margin as initially claimed in the article. Also, this is retail flow, likely there isn't much information to extract for Citadel.