6 ms·
There has been a very long and public design process involved in this [1]. Some of the final contenders were not what I would have expected to see even consider
by wodenokoto 10y ago
There has been a very long and public design process involved in this [1]. Some of the final contenders were not what I would have expected to see even considered [2].
I think it is good that Mozilla stuck to a geeky expression.
[1] https://blog.mozilla.org/opendesign/ https://blog.mozilla.org/opendesign/
[2] https://blog.mozilla.org/opendesign/now-for-the-fun-part/ https://blog.mozilla.org/opendesign/now-for-the-fun-part/
- aaron-lebo 10y agoVery glad they skipped the Sauron-eye. Not sure how that even got as far along as it did. This kind of seems like the best of a bunch of mediocre concepts. Instead of having a design agency do the logos and then selecting from them, it would have been interesting to take designs from the community - surely some more interesting designs would have been proposed.
- cptskippy 10y agoIt's OK to say "These all suck" rather than choosing the least crappy option. I've been using Firefox since it's inception and the Communicator Suite before that. To me this just screams out as a plea for attention to the younger generations. This is like some weird episode of Saved By The Bell where Mr Belding puts on jeans and a ball cap to try and fit in with Zach and Slater.
- pluma 10y agoOkay, looking at the second link, I'm glad they went with the least horrible one out of the bunch, but the better decision still would have been not to use any of them. The "eye" looks like either the Eye of Sauron (i.e. evil) or a stylized vagina (i.e. inappropriate). The "connector" is cute but useless for branding because it becomes excessively generic. The "open" looks like someone mixed a console icon with an insurance company's logo. The "wireframe" is bland with weak typography. The "impossible M" is appropriate for a conference but not a company. It also just doesn't work at smaller scales or with other colors. The "flik flak" is not even a logo. These aren't good designs for their purpose. The "moz://a" logo isn't good but it's vastly more appropriate than the rest of them.
- 542458 10y agoJeepers these comments are pessimistic. Am I the only one who actually likes what they went with? I think it's cool, does a good job of differentiating from MS, Google and Apple's respective styles, and reflects Mozilla's less "corporate" nature. There are some solid ideas in the other concepts as well (although I will admit some of them are a tad underdeveloped, and the all-seeing eye probably projects the wrong image).
- flukus 10y agoI wonder if they've considered changing the name to something more marketable? Their firefox marketing has always been top notch but the mozilla stuff has always been pretty terrible.
- Steko 10y agoHere's my proposal: rebrand as Firefox and use the Firefox logo.
- holygoat 10y agoThat's actually the current state of affairs. Firefox, and Firefox-related products, hang out under the Firefox umbrella brand. Mozilla's policy, outreach, community, and education initiatives -- remember, Mozilla is a non-profit -- use the Mozilla brand. Mozilla hasn't been a product brand for a long time.
- toyg 10y agoDid they actually pay anyone for this stuff? It looks like the sort of thing 16-year-olds would come up with (including the one they actually chose). Very low level all around.