4 ms·
Funny that they only worry about that now that Republicans are taking over. Reportedly, Obama ordered just such a deletion of records. http://thehill.com/blog
by leereeves 10y ago
Funny that they only worry about that now that Republicans are taking over.
Reportedly, Obama ordered just such a deletion of records.
http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/homeland-security/268282-dhs-ordered-me-to-scrub-records-of-muslims-with-terror http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/homeland-security/268...
- knz 10y agoIs there anything in this article that actually links the deletion to President Obama or explains why the deletion was ordered? Or even any evidence that this happened? Edit to be clear: I'm not implying the Obama administration did not do things like this but this read more like an anecdote by someone with political leanings. We also have no information about why they were deleted or modified and don't know if the author had access to the full picture. Perhaps they were merged with another record, therefore improving the "haystack" etc.
- leereeves 10y agoThe author made that connection: "the Obama administration was ordering they be wiped away." I haven't seen any followup on this story. Liberal media seems to have ignored it entirely, conservative media reports it without further details. The author, Philip Haney, has been a vocal critic, appearing on Fox and writing numerous articles, so there's been ample opportunity for the Obama administration to respond if there was indeed an explanation such as you suggest, but I haven't seen any response.
- wavefunction 10y agoI'm sure the Obama administration is just far too busy with finally getting around to the FEMA camps and gun confiscation to answer every little conservative conspiracy claim.
- mistermann 10y agoMaybe he's too busy closing down Gitmo right?
- 1024core 10y agoYou can't say he didn't try. But the Republican response was so over the top, portraying the prisoners as some sort of supervillains with superpowers, that it never happened. I don't know why the Republicans are so scared of these prisoners.
- leereeves 10y agoAnd sharing NSA data (obtained without a warrant) with the Justice Department? https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/01/obama-expands-surveillance-powers-his-way-out https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/01/obama-expands-surveill... Can't blame that one on Republicans.
- willstrafach 10y agoIf you are actually interested in getting an understanding of what happened, you may want to read the declassified source document instead of reading the EFF's take on an incorrect portion of the NYT article.
- leereeves 10y agoOr you could share what you know that you think the NYT writer did not.
- mistermann 10y agoI'm far from an expert on these things, but is this a mischaracterization in your opinion? https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/feb/24/obama-guantanamo-bay-closure-republicans https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/feb/24/obama-guanta... Just one example: "The day before the Archives speech, the Democratic-held Senate dealt Obama’s plans an even harsher blow. By a blowout bipartisan margin of 90-9, the Senate rejected financing the closure. A Senate leadership aide at the time, stunned by what she considered White House lassitude, explained why even people inclined to help Obama would vote against the measure: Obama had decreed Guantánamo be closed without presenting lawmakers with a specific plan they could defend to skeptical constituents." To be fair though, there's a lot in that article to justify getting angry at both Democrats and Republicans. For example: "As implied by the term, Graham spent the summer of 2009 looking beyond Guantánamo. His basic proposition to the White House, reported in detail in Charlie Savage’s 2015 book Power Wars, was to deliver the votes in the Senate for shuttering Guantánamo and opening a replacement facility. In exchange, Graham wanted a broader wartime detentions policy than Obama was willing to embrace. It would allow the US military to continue making captures far beyond the declared battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan, sending them to the alternative site. When trial was an option, it would occur in the military commissions." Dirty politics, absolutely unacceptable (to me). These things are extremely complicated. I really dislike this simplistic recurring narrative (not you specifically, I'm speaking in general) that everything is the Republican's fault. I have no problem believing this is usually true, it is the implicit assertion that it is always true that bothers me. Although, the Republicans now have a historic opportunity to show their true colors with no excuses....I am ready to be extremely disappointed.
- bb611 10y agoThere is no equivalency between deleting criminal justice records, which should and normally do remain private unless used in a court of law, and removing information that's been released the public sphere.
- leereeves 10y ago"After leaving my 15 year career at DHS, I can no longer be silent about the dangerous state of America’s counter-terror strategy, our leaders’ willingness to compromise the security of citizens for the ideological rigidity of political correctness—and, consequently, our vulnerability to devastating, mass-casualty attack." Both are stories about deleting information that doesn't fit a political agenda. There's an option between releasing and deleting information about suspected terrorists. Unless you're saying the suspected terrorists were cleared? If so, what's your source?
- bb611 10y ago> Both are stories about deleting information that doesn't fit a political agenda. One set of information is public, one is private. The information we're discussing is public - this recently released trove of CIA documents and NOAA & NASA climate data for instance. The DHS' internal database of terrorism suspects is private unless used specifically to prosecute individuals for crimes. If your claim is that the DHS should publicly release data about terrorism suspects, that's another debate, although a spurious one. We've done that before, it was called McCarthyism, and it left an indelible negative mark on the US government. If DHS were to engage in such behavior it would likely be challenged and reversed on 6th amendment grounds.
- leereeves 10y agoMy claim is that tracking terrorists is important, not that such information should be made public. Information about terrorists should remain private, but it shouldn't be deleted.
- 10y ago
- cmdrfred 10y agoRemember how loud Obama screamed when the CIA "lost" that torture report. Oh wait. He was silent on that one. Both parties love secrets. If the public knew what they were up to they would all be out on their asses next election cycle.
- boomboomsubban 10y ago... How can someone work at the DHS for fifteen years in February 2016?