2 ms·
Look -- I have no desire to kick around global warming yet again, and I won't, but in the category of "being a good defense of one's opinions" this is awful tri
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Look -- I have no desire to kick around global warming yet again, and I won't, but in the category of "being a good defense of one's opinions" this is awful tripe. Even supporters should be able to recognize that.
My alarm went off early with I have no academic stance on human-caused global warming except that, as a scientist reviewing the issue from an evolutionary perspective, if humans are even partly the cause of the warming since 1990 then we are already doomed as a species
So you have no academic stance, but as a "scientist reviewing the issue from an evolutionary perspective" we're all going to die? Would this be as a non-academic scientist? And wtf is a non-academic scientist, anyway? And although as an academic you have no stance, you think we're all going to die as somebody else? Still working that out.
He continues the barely cogent rambling for several graphs. Was there alcohol involved with the creation of this essay?
Then his claim that by making a reasoned judgment on a fuzzy measurement, somehow the measurement becomes intellectual property assigned to the measurer? If this were true, umpires, anybody reading a meniscus, and makers of fuzzy-logic thermostats could lay claim to vast swaths of intellectual property overnight.
This is probably a brilliant man. My guess is that it was a hurried email more than a well-reasoned polemic. This guy needed an editor, and in a bad way. I think the Guardian let him down and did a disservice to the entire AGCC cause by letting him go with this terrible, terrible essay.