4 ms·
Design experiment(s) that would invalidate hypothesis. This is the sticking point with nutrition and medical studies though. With the existence of IRB's and me
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
Design experiment(s) that would invalidate hypothesis.
This is the sticking point with nutrition and medical studies though. With the existence of IRB's and medical ethics practices, it's challenging and best and impossible at worst to run medical experiments up to scientific standards. Maybe rightly so, but it does put handcuffs on the ability to do hypothesis based testing for nutrition.
- savanaly 10y agoSame reason economists have such a hard time making robust theories.
- civility 10y agoSame reason paleontology, geology, anthropology, climate science, astronomy, and so on have a difficult time... Any theory that can't be falsified by running an experiment shouldn't be called "science". At best, people pick the theories they believe because they "fit" existing observations, not because it's good science. (No computer models really aren't good enough - you have to ask whether the model was correct and included all the important components)
- mattkrause 10y agoI really don't think that IRBs/ethics committees are the major problem in biomedical research. Interacting with them can be frustrating and annoying, but the issues were largely bureaucratic ones (so many forms and approvals). I've never felt like their requests were unreasonable or that they compromised the research. On the other hand, the continual pressure to publish "complete" stories, early and often, absolutely affects the quality of research and I think finding ways to realign researchers' incentives would be awesome.