4 ms·
Idlewords always a good read, the history of Scurvy and Vitamin C has some great content relating to science and diet, how difficult it is to get conclusive evi
by jodrellblank 10y ago
Idlewords always a good read, the history of Scurvy and Vitamin C has some great content relating to science and diet, how difficult it is to get conclusive evidence, and how easy it is to jump to the wrong conclusions over and over:
http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm http://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm
including quotes / sections:
- It has been known since antiquity that fresh foods in general, and lemons and oranges in particular, will cure scurvy. Starting with Vasco de Gama’s crew in 1497, sailors have repeatedly discovered the curative power of citrus fruits, and the cure has just as frequently been forgotten or ignored by subsequent explorers.
- 1747, James Lind proved in one of the first controlled medical experiments that citrus fruits were an effective cure for the disease. [..] the experiment involved two sailors eating oranges for six days. Lind went on to propound a completely ineffective method of preserving lemon juice (by boiling it down), which he never thought to test.
- Knowing that citrus fruits deferred scurvy, but not knowing why, assuming it was to do with acidity, and switching to a cheaper British source of 'limes' instead of a foreign source of 'limes' - and accidentally switching from effective fruit to ineffective fruit, without noticing.
- Knowing that citrus fruits avoided scurvy, but not knowing that copper breaks down Vitamin C, and keeping the juice in copper containers on ship.
- the time Pasteurized milk was found to be better for preventing bacterial infection in infants, so rich parents switched to it. And the heating denatured Vitamin C so their children developed scurvy. Poor children, being breast fed, didn't get scurvy, only richer children.
- The sickness could be fitted to so many theories of disease—imbalance in vital humors, bad air, acidification of the blood, bacterial infection—that despite the existence of an unambigous cure, there was always a raft of alternative, ineffective treatments. At no point did physicians express doubt about their theories, however ineffective.
- Finally, that one of the simplest of diseases managed to utterly confound us for so long, at the cost of millions of lives, even after we had stumbled across an unequivocal cure. It makes you wonder how many incurable ailments of the modern world—depression, autism, hypertension, obesity—will turn out to have equally simple solutions, once we are able to see them in the correct light. What will we be slapping our foreheads about sixty years from now, wondering how we missed something so obvious?
And plenty of other things they thought about ptomaines, contaminated tinned food, stuffy air, lack of light, poisons to avoid, and all without good experiments and with plenty of grabbing a ray of hope and committing everything based on it.