2 ms·
In at least one picture, there is a shrimp boat towing booms. Going full tilt on cleanup is probably not a good idea. For instance cleaning up oiled birds may
by whyenot 16y ago
In at least one picture, there is a shrimp boat towing booms.
Going full tilt on cleanup is probably not a good idea.
For instance cleaning up oiled birds may seem like the right thing to do, but the unfortunate reality is that even if you remove the oil from their feathers, the vast majority will die from shock and organ failure. Most experts believe the most humane course is actually to euthanize oiled birds. http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,693359,00.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,693359,00.h...
The same goes for other forms of cleanup, for instance aggressively cleaning fragile areas such as marshes may cause additional damage for little if any benefit. Dispersants are themselves toxic, and overuse may cause more harm than good.
THE best thing to do in response to the Gulf spill’s landfall is ... nothing. Sure, larger oil concentrations can be sopped up, and large animals can be cleaned. But cleanup efforts can do only so much: evidence suggests that they reduce hydrocarbon concentrations only over the short term. And many responses have harmful side effects. Controlled burning spreads toxic materials and kills plants that retard erosion, thus hurting the very lands we’re trying to protect. Nutrient-rich detergents or active bioremediation — which encourages the growth of bacteria that can break down oil — can fundamentally disturb the ecological balance for decades.
Instead, we should recognize that nature can do many things far better than we can, and with less collateral damage. Oil is a natural byproduct of biological and geological processes; if left alone in coastal environments, wave action, the sun and microbes in the sediment will naturally break down hydrocarbons. Meanwhile, money saved can go to helping local economies deal with the loss of income, improving safety regulations and enforcement and developing a clean energy policy. — KEVIN M. YEAGER, assistant professor of marine sciences at the University of Southern Mississippi http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/11/opinion/11oped2.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/11/opinion/11oped2.html
- tmsh 16y agoSurely, setting up booms to contain the oil (which is still flowing, and apparently will be for another couple of months until this relief well is done) would do much to limit the expanse of the spill. This is not a completed oil spill. It is one growing by the day. Surely, containing the oil from spreading is at least something that should be attempted. You say: 'In at least one picture, there is a shrimp boat towing booms.' That is precisely my point. If that works, there should be more of it.