6 ms·
Whistle blowing requires the knowledge of wrong doing, and exposing these wrong doings. As far as I am aware that guy leaked the data in bulk without looking a
by cm2187 10y ago
Whistle blowing requires the knowledge of wrong doing, and exposing these wrong doings.
As far as I am aware that guy leaked the data in bulk without looking at it, and without any knowledge of the US diplomacy, and the leaks didn't expose any major wrongdoing. Only some gory videos, that don't really teach us anything (everyone knows bombs make "collateral damages", the US army even maintains statistics on them). And everything I read from people who reviewed the diplomatic cables suggest that US diplomats are doing rather well their jobs.
I am a libertarian, pro-pardoning Snowden, who did expose deliberately major wrong doings. But I am struggling to call Manning a whistleblower.
- TillE 10y ago> Only some gory videos, that don't really teach us anything (everyone knows bombs make "collateral damages" So you've never actually watched (or read about) the Collateral Murder video, huh? It's a helicopter crew killing people with guns, not bombs. And they kill exactly who they intend to. Maybe don't form strong opinions when you don't have the slightest clue what the facts are.
- mason240 10y agoManning had no knowledge of the video. It happened to be in the blind data dump.
- hendersoon 10y agoThat is not true, and is easily verifiable by reading Chelsea's chat logs with Adrian Lamo.
- cm2187 10y agoAs far as I know they have mistaken a TV crew for some armed people. Big deal. This sort of fuckups happen all the time in any war. That's called "collateral damage". If you don't want any you can't shoot on people from a helicopter 300m away from your target, through a low res B&W video. In fact there are very few things any army could do if we wanted to have zero collateral damage. When congress authorizes a war, the reality is that they authorize the fact that these things may happen. I'm not pro-Irak war, quite the contrary. But the fact that civilians have been killed isn't exactly a hidden secret that was uncovered by the leaks > Maybe don't form strong opinions when you don't have the slightest clue what the facts are. This sort of insults has nothing to do on HN
- HerraBRE 10y agoThe "collateral murder" video, which was based on Manning's leaks, is really quite chilling and definitely shows wrong doings that were then covered up by the government. There was more, but this was the most visual/memorable. I suggest you turn your scepticism to 11 and go watch it, see if you still feel the same way. https://collateralmurder.wikileaks.org/ https://collateralmurder.wikileaks.org/ (warning: if watching civilians, journalists and children being killed in cold blood bothers you, maybe don't go watch it, just read about it instead)
- pvg 10y agoThe incident had been reported and covered by the press, there was no 'government cover up'. The new bit was the video itself.
- HerraBRE 10y agoGovernment stonewalling then, the government wasn't exactly forthcoming. Reuters had been fighting for information for quite some time.
- manarth 10y agoThe new bit was the video itself. Saying "X happened", and offering "Here is video that demonstrates X happened" are very different things. A video of an event can be of such overwhelming significance that its importance is impossible to calculate.
- pvg 10y agoNot the case for this incident. You don't have to speculate, you can just read the wikipedia page. For instance, a reporter for the Washington Post was able to reconstruct the incident and write a book about it without seeing the video. 'Collateral murder' is much more notable for the Wikileaks editorializing than for its actual news value.
- manarth 10y ago
- adrienne 10y agoChelsea Manning is a woman; please do not misgender her by referring to her as "that guy".
- omginternets 10y agoUgghhhhh. Please stop baiting. If it makes you feel better, assume the OP was referring to sex and not gender. If it doesn't, please understand that not everybody shares your political inclinations with respect to gender-theory and identity.
- adrienne 10y agoPeople's identities are not a "political inclination" and to say they are is transphobic.
- omginternets 10y agoAnd there it is.