3 ms·
It depends on the jurisdiction, sure. But in this case the jurisdiction was California, the most pro labor state in the US. I don't believe their lawyers or th
by stale2002 10y ago
It depends on the jurisdiction, sure. But in this case the jurisdiction was California, the most pro labor state in the US.
I don't believe their lawyers or the companies are incompetent. I believe that they were actively malicious.
They thought that the legal costs of getting caught and losing the lawsuit, or settling, would be less than following the law, so they actively chose to take the risk and break the law.
And it turns out, they were mostly correct about that. Doesn't mean that they shouldn't be condemned for it.
This is backed up by all the statements that they made about "don't put this stuff in writing! ", ect. And the fact that they stopped engaging in these practices. (if they were doing nothing wrong, then they would continue, right?)
- cookiecaper 10y agoIs a lawyer not incompetent if he green-lights the corporation's involvement in an actively malicious scheme?
- stale2002 10y agoNo. It is actually a smart(but evil) thing to do, if you think the courts won't fine you that much. X billion gain > Y billion loss. These companies won. They saved more money than they lost. From a business standpoint, it was a good idea to break the law, and get sued.