3 ms·
A Big Test for Big Batteries
- terravion 10y agoDoes anyone here have any context for whether the concerns about AES and Tesla batteries is at all founded or is it just journalistic hype? I find it hard to believe that those companies haven't thought through battery management at this scale. They both have pretty solid engineering records and ability to deliver--not saying new things don't have teething problems--but fires and explosions?
- stcredzero 10y agoThe writing is on the wall, in terms of $/energy going down with Li-ion. Perhaps pressure to be first is pushing companies to shave margins a bit too much? Perhaps, it's a case of being a bit too soon?
- skybrian 10y agoFire and explosions are indeed a risk when something goes wrong. I'm sure they thought it through, but that's why lithium batteries need safety systems. https://electrek.co/2016/12/19/tesla-fire-powerpack-test-safety/ https://electrek.co/2016/12/19/tesla-fire-powerpack-test-saf...
- epistasis 10y agoEverything has risks, but the risks of a lithium-ion battery fire are pretty small compared to the huge gas leak that was part of the motivation for trying batteries.
- spangry 10y agoIn AES' case at least, it sounds like this is their main value-add. According to the article they don't manufacture their own Li-ion cells, so my guess is they're more in the business of building and installing 'safe' enclosures that can withstand (and contain) catastrophic battery failure.
- stcredzero 10y agoWhat about liquid metal batteries? http://www.ted.com/talks/donald_sadoway_the_missing_link_to_renewable_energy?language=en http://www.ted.com/talks/donald_sadoway_the_missing_link_to_... From a naive/quick glance taking a Musk style "first principles" look at them, being made of elements that are literally "dirt cheap" and available in major construction project quantities would seem to be a decisive advantage. EDIT: Seems they ran into major problems with seals: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/541851/race-for-a-new-grid-battery-hits-a-speed-bump/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/541851/race-for-a-new-gri...
- walrus01 10y agoI am not aware of any that are actually shipping as commercial products that I can buy with a net30 PO, everything so far is PR fluff, lab test and field beta tests.
- taneq 10y agoGoing back 15-20 years, there was the ZEBRA battery which was looking pretty good. I don't know what happened to it. According to ZEVA the power output was fairly low so maybe that was the issue.[1] At least one company[2] is pretty close to bringing a redox flow battery to market, which should have most of the advantages of molten salt / liquid metal batteries without the downside of having to keep it molten. The limiting factor seems to be electrode lifespan but even then the cycle life is huge (~3600-4000 full discharge cycles). Also from the numbers they give, round trip efficiency seems a bit lower (~80%) than LiIon / LiPoly. [1] http://zeva.com.au/Tech/Batteries/ http://zeva.com.au/Tech/Batteries/ [2] http://redflow.com/ http://redflow.com/
- philipkglass 10y agoAES just landed an even bigger battery storage deal in Hawaii: http://www.utilitydive.com/news/hawaii-co-op-signs-deal-for-solarstorage-project-at-11kwh http://www.utilitydive.com/news/hawaii-co-op-signs-deal-for-... In California and Hawaii these storage projects will mostly be used in tandem with intermittent renewables. But batteries can convert any slowly-adjustable (or non-adjustable) electricity source into serving daily peaks. If nuclear plants could store some of their low-value output at 3 AM to serve the early evening demand peak around 6 PM, for example, it could increase the revenue they get from the same number of megawatt-hours. At today's storage prices that sort of electricity arbitrage isn't profitable but if storage gets cheap it will have broad impacts on the engineering and economics of electricity systems. It's not just about enabling higher renewable penetration, though that will be a big story too.
- walrus01 10y agoIt's worth mentioning that grid power to the consumer is something like $0.36/kWh in Hawaii right now, which makes off grid PV with even old shitty AGM lead acid battery technology more economical.
- sk5t 10y agoRefrigerators aside, isn't home electricity usage pretty low in Hawaii?
- walrus01 10y agoFor heating, yeah, but not for air conditioning and other stuff...
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThat's sort of the way these things go. First, Tesla, AES and others deploy to the most expensive power markets (islands mostly, or anywhere diesel is the primary generation technology for electricity; but also locations where expensive natural gas peaker plants are used). Then, more batteries are made. As more are made, they get cheaper. This allows for even more batteries to be installed. My prediction is you'll see the demise of any sort of combustion fuel for electrical grid generation in the next 10-15 years. Batteries (tens of GWs of production are coming online; the scale is truly massive) will simply keep getting cheaper at the same time solar and wind do. Nuclear is probably going to die too unfortunately; its too costly and doesn't get paid for its zero carbon footprint (the solution there would be to use targeted EV credits to increase the uptake of electric vehicles in certain markets, shifting dollars from petrol consumption to night time nuclear consumption; I can get power for $0.01/kwh between midnight at 6am from ComEd in Northern Illinois from their merchant nuclear fleet, which is the ideal time to charge your EV).
- delbel 10y agoPoliticizing an engineering problem always fails, but this time I can't wait to buy these batteries on ebay sold as refurbished, when the politicians and executives come to the realization the project won't meet their expectations -- because the battery technology just isn't there yet, and they have to switch back to diesel generators. Like the ones we've been using since the 1930s (even before that) to deal with problems like this.
- epistasis 10y agoWho's doing the politicization here, though? The energy industry has been hyper-politicized for decades, and highly biased against changing technologies. The batteries are going to work as engineered, it's straightforward technology. The only question is the cost of those batteries. This is also not a huge amount of batteries compared to, say, electric car batteries.
- woodandsteel 10y agoMy admittedly ill-informed understanding is that flow batteries have the best basic characteristics for utility electric storage. Anybody know how they are coming along?