3 ms·
Are you saying you where talking metaphorically? Because the metaphor compares two similar things. Also, why is a metaphor needed here?
by Chris2048 10y ago
Are you saying you where talking metaphorically? Because the metaphor compares two similar things.
Also, why is a metaphor needed here?
- coldtea 10y ago>Are you saying you where talking metaphorically? Because the metaphor compares two similar things. A metaphor compares two things similar from a certain aspect -- they could still differ in every other way. One could use a metaphor from agriculture to clarify their point on a political issue, for example. >Also, why is a metaphor needed here? For the same reasons that it's needed elsewhere. To get the point across in a simplified way, because people can understand a phenomenon better in one domain than they can in another (aka "domain dependence").
- Chris2048 10y ago> A metaphor compares two things similar from a certain aspect When I said "the metaphor compares two similar thing" I didn't mean metaphors in general, I meant your metaphor specifically compares two things that are similar. The relevant differences between NY and the moon do not exist between NY and Illinois. > For the same reasons that it's needed elsewhere Metaphors are often of dubious value. They can be used to clarify unfamiliar situation, where the bounds of the metaphor are clear; or, perhaps as in this case, encourage similar thinking about two related concepts. But you provided a metaphor here without providing clarity on what the point was. When I think "why would I build a city in Illinois, when there already one in NY", none of the answers I come up with apply equally to the moon. e.g. land is cheaper/convenient (not on the moon), the scenery is better (maybe true, but not to outweight other more pressing concerns) etc.