4 ms·

Gizmodo (http://gizmodo.com/5537316 http://gizmodo.com/5537316) is claiming they've seen the 5 patents which HTC is allegedly suing with. "Two are related to p

Gizmodo (http://gizmodo.com/5537316 http://gizmodo.com/5537316) is claiming they've seen the 5 patents which HTC is allegedly suing with. "Two are related to power management, two are over personalized phone dialers, and one's over a telephone dialer with easy access memory—pretty menial stuff, compared to everything Apple is slamming HTC with."

apgwoz 16y ago
Does it matter how menial the patent claims are? If Apple is indeed infringing, then HTC has the choice to offer a license at whatever cost they want, do they not? HTC is in the same boat. If HTC is found to have violated any of Apple's patents, Apply too can slam HTC for licensing fees or whatever else.
- rubyrescue 16y ago
  i've been involved in a few of these... it matters because ultimately it could come down to a jury trial and then a judge's decision regarding damages. how 'big' the claims are matters to the real people making the decisions in the courtroom. they're not going to award billions of dollars of damages for a minor claim, for instance, and claims can sometimes be worked around, so often the damage done to the infringed party is what's at stake, plus penalties. (admittedly, this is an oversimplification) i've sat in a room full of people discussing these issues ad nauseam and i can tell you with 100% confidence that this is like a poker game, the size of the chip stack affects the confidence, timing, positioning, etc, of the players throughout the whole game. if one side has a great set of claims and the other doesn't, it definitely matters.
ergo98 16y ago
Apple is suing HTC over a swipe unlock, power management, and various other menial stuff.
- ajross 16y ago
  Don't forget "bouncing" the display when it reaches the end of the scrollable area! And of course the stunning innovation of holding two fingers down at once.
technomancy 16y ago
They're software patents. They're trivial by definition.

apgwoz 16y ago

Does it matter how menial the patent claims are? If Apple is indeed infringing, then HTC has the choice to offer a license at whatever cost they want, do they not? HTC is in the same boat. If HTC is found to have violated any of Apple's patents, Apply too can slam HTC for licensing fees or whatever else.

rubyrescue 16y ago
i've been involved in a few of these... it matters because ultimately it could come down to a jury trial and then a judge's decision regarding damages. how 'big' the claims are matters to the real people making the decisions in the courtroom. they're not going to award billions of dollars of damages for a minor claim, for instance, and claims can sometimes be worked around, so often the damage done to the infringed party is what's at stake, plus penalties. (admittedly, this is an oversimplification) i've sat in a room full of people discussing these issues ad nauseam and i can tell you with 100% confidence that this is like a poker game, the size of the chip stack affects the confidence, timing, positioning, etc, of the players throughout the whole game. if one side has a great set of claims and the other doesn't, it definitely matters.

ergo98 16y ago

Apple is suing HTC over a swipe unlock, power management, and various other menial stuff.

ajross 16y ago
Don't forget "bouncing" the display when it reaches the end of the scrollable area! And of course the stunning innovation of holding two fingers down at once.

technomancy 16y ago

They're software patents. They're trivial by definition.