9 ms·
> So in conclusion, I really do hope that HTML5 isn’t to be the future of the web, for we will have missed a chance to really make the future web great if it tu
by alanh 17y ago
> So in conclusion, I really do hope that HTML5 isn’t to be the future of the web, for we will have missed a chance to really make the future web great if it turns out to be so.
This final sentence perfectly demonstrates the unfounded, poorly-written, wordy wishful thinking of the entire article. Don’t waste your time.
- - -
He also demonstrates an utter failure to grasp the HTML5 timeline, or why the DOM matters, or that his "alternative" is nothing more or less than requiring all browsers to support a theoretical open-source release of Java applets / Silverlight / Flash / similar.
From one of the author's comments: "I do not see the canvas tag and flash as doing essentially the same thing. Rendering text in a canvas tag would be an odd thing to do for example." Ah! Precisely: one would have to add a shiv to allow <canvas> text to be selected and copied, and it wouldn't quite work the same as it would on the rest of the page; text would be anti-aliased differently than system text; etc. Remind you of anything — Flash, perhaps? He's arguing against himself here.
- alanh 17y agoFWIW: The crazy font for the headings on http://gowallatools.com/api/ http://gowallatools.com/api/ are done with JS & <canvas>. So it is quite possible to “do” text in Canvas, even selection; but it’s clearly awkward (like Flash). Screenshot in Google Chrome OS X: http://skitch.com/alanhogan/dd8us/highlighting-canvas-text http://skitch.com/alanhogan/dd8us/highlighting-canvas-text