14 ms·
Authoritarians Distract Rather Than Debate
- bbctol 10y agoTitle might want to be altered: this is a description of a specific research paper analyzing Chinese online propaganda campaigns, not as general an analysis as the title indicates. Interesting stuff!
- nabla9 10y agoRAND has study says the same about Russia. The Russian "Firehose of Falsehood" Propaganda Model Why It Might Work and Options to Counter It http://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE198.html http://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE198.html
- cryoshon 10y agoThanks for the excellent link, I've been looking for a documentary on Putin's propaganda regime that I saw a few years ago, but this paper is a much deeper look which will serve the same purpose.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoIf you want more context on Putin's regime, check out, "Nothing is True and Everything is Possible" by Peter Pomerantsev. It's an inside view of Russian life/propaganda from someone who worked as a TV producer for a Russian network: https://www.amazon.com/Nothing-True-Everything-Possible-Surreal/dp/1610396006 https://www.amazon.com/Nothing-True-Everything-Possible-Surr...
- ConfuciusSay02 10y agoRemember that RAND was one of the big cheerleaders for the Iraq war. If you want an impartial analysis, you're not going to find it from war-mongering "think tank" imbeciles.
- jtcond13 10y agoIt's a reference to the nonsense 'controversies' created by Donald Trump.
- bbctol 10y agoYes, but the link isn't actually about that.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoPretty fascinating stuff. I'm not sure what Trump's arm of this kind of propaganda is, but Correct the Record was a very real thing, despite the bogeyman descriptions of it in some online communities. https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00578997 https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00578997 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correct_the_Record https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correct_the_Record Interestingly, the original website is now gone, but it used to say essentially that it advocated for Clinton across Reddit, Facebook, Twitter, and other forms of social media. http://www.correctrecord.org/ http://www.correctrecord.org/ The scary thing is just how cheap it would be to pay people to sit in online communities and drive attention to and away from whatever you wanted. Even more interesting is in 10 years it'll be like it never existed. Spread some propaganda, pack up, and go home.
- cryoshon 10y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, CTR is a perfect example of this phenomenon operating within the USA, albeit in a slightly different context than in China. The US government likely has similar programs going on here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JTRIG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JTRIG
- LyndsySimon 10y ago> I'm not sure what Trump's arm of this kind of propaganda is In all seriousness - it's /pol/. See also /r/The_Donald, gab.ai, and a handful of niche forums. As an aside, I'm sad that gab.ai hasn't seen adoption outside that political group. It's really got a lot of potential as a platform.
- MichaelGG 10y agoDo you have any links about paid propaganda on /pol/?
- LyndsySimon 10y agoI've not seen any allegations of that. I'm not saying it's paid, I'm saying it's his propaganda arm. They serve the function, officially or not.
- tristanj 10y agoI'm not sure what's especially revealing about this story. A lot of the content we already knew, except now there's more evidence of it. The marginalrevolution author wrongly suggests that "it has long been assumed that propaganda posts would support the government with praise or criticize critics of the government" and says it's surprising this paper found it wasn't. This is no surprise, others have concluded this before this has been known probably a decade. Kudos for the authors to write this paper though, it takes courage to do this. For most people skimming the comment section, this interview here with a paid Chinese "online commentator" is far more revealing than submitted article is: http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/politics/2012/10/china%E2%80%99s-paid-trolls-meet-50-cent-party http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/politics/2012/10/china%... The commentator estimates 10-20% of posts on Chinese media are by "online commentators" like him, and he also talks about the methods he uses to guide and manipulate the discussion.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoGary King is a pretty prominent political scientist. It's unlikely that this is unoriginal work. Yes, that's an appeal to authority, but I think the methods used are what's novel. And don't discount just having some evidence! Here's the article: http://gking.harvard.edu/50c http://gking.harvard.edu/50c edit: it's also in the apsr, which is one of the poli sci journals. There are a lot less people doing this kind of analysis in an academic setting than one might expect.
- wuschel 10y agoThank you for the link. The comments of the thought influencer do remind me the distorted discussions in the Economist's comment section I followed a couple of years ago. The topics that were heavily spammed were usually revolving about Chinese politics or economics.
- analyst74 10y agoThis is really scary, because I do read comments critically, and have seen those sections being flooded with nonsense, or convincing arguments being pushed without evidence. Heck, this even happens on HackerNews, which users are thoughtful hackers and which are secretly trying to push an agenda? Or is there even a line between those? Now some food for thought, does online anonymity ultimately help the powerful more than the general public?
- LyndsySimon 10y ago> which users are thoughtful hackers and which are secretly trying to push an agenda? Or is there even a line between those? I don't think there is a line. Each of us pushes an agenda (our own). That's never going to change, and I wouldn't want it to. > does online anonymity ultimately help the powerful more than the general public? I don't do online anonymity :)
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIt's fine for you to push your own agenda. But push an agenda that is honestly yours, not one that you're being paid to push. And push it honestly, not pretending to be something you're not.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI've noticed it, too. It looks like the public has gone mad. (Or perhaps like they're trying to gaslight us.) But if the Chinese are doing this, and the Russians, and maybe the DNC and the RNC... that would explain why the public conversation has become so weird.
- ConfuciusSay02 10y agoMaybe the DNC? They openly had whole organizations with budgets in the millions whose sole purpose was to influence opinion online. We also know thanks to Snowden that the US government has long had operational programs to influence and subvert online discussion. At this point I'd estimate a minimum of 30% of all posts online, including HN, are done by people with an agenda whether political or financial.
- VLM 10y agoIts interesting to compare the behavior observations in the article to the concept of "concern trolling" which is almost the same.
- devoply 10y ago> …find a massive government effort, where every year the 50c party writes approximately 448 million social media posts nationwide. About 52.7% of these posts appear on government sites. The remaining 212 million posts are inserted into the stream of approximately 80 billion total posts on commercial social media sites, all in real time. If these estimates are correct, a large proportion of government web site comments, and about one of every 178 social media posts on commercial sites, are fabricated by the government. The posts are not randomly distributed but, as we show in Figure 2, are highly focused and directed, all with specific intent and content. This is massive. But I am sure Western governments are paying attention as to how to combat online opinion using similar tactics. But I doubt they can match that sort of scale with their economies. Indian freelancers aren't really going to be that convincing to the American public.
- wu-ikkyu 10y ago>But I doubt they can match that sort of scale with their economies. Chatbots scale much easier than manual astroturfing.
- monocle 10y agoIn China the government hires people to sway public opinion. In the US, special interests and those with money do it. Is it worse that the Chinese government does it to "keep the peace", while those in the US do it to get your money? Super PACs, political activists, pharmaceutical companies, Reddit power users, brigades and pay-for-votes services... not sure if there's any real difference.
- Chickenality 10y agoOne major difference is how concentrated the special interests are. In the case of the Chinese government, public opinion is being swayed by a single entity. In the US, a large number of interest groups are all competing to try to sway public opinion. In the latter case, I think it's harder (at least in principle) for any one group to have a large effect on its own.
- danharaj 10y agoExcept in the common intersection of their interests.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoExcept, centralization of wealth means that the opinions of a relatively few people control the seeming surface diversity of "influencers" in the USA by holding the purse strings (when the proles resort to crowd funding they can break out of this to an extent, Bernie being an example).
- stcredzero 10y agoThe elites rig the elections and the public sphere, while the proles use the one election where they can still sway the vote to vote for dangerous populists as a protest. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trrqslUpfdw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trrqslUpfdw Old republican values are relegated to the dustbin, and a civilization becomes a shadow of its former self. This has happened before, and will happen again.
- 10y ago
- grabcocque 10y agoThank god media doesn't try to distract us with trivial minutiae in the West, eh?
- cryoshon 10y agoYep. This is real in the US, too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JTRIG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JTRIG & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Strategic_Counterterrorism_Communications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Strategic_Counterte... & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Earnest_Voice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Earnest_Voice. Sure, these are officially targeted at enemies of the state, outside the US. But we have proof that they lie about these things preventatively as well as reactively. I imagine that in China as well as here, their shills are skilled at disruption and redirection.
- importantbrian 10y agoThis reminds me of the storyline from Newsroom where Neal tries to infiltrate the troll underground. The scary thing is how effective this kind of manipulation can be. I often check the comments on HN before reading the article to see if it's going to be worth my time. With sports or controversial news articles I love to jump to the comments to see what the debate is. I like to think of myself as a critical thinker, but I often find myself getting swept up in my own confirmation bias. Upvoting the comments I agree with and downvoting those I don't, almost mindlessly without really evaluating the arguments. It's the more modern version of the cable news network shows where they put a Republican on one side and a Democrat on the other and let them yell their talking points at each other while the host interjects every so often to stir the pot. I hate that it appeals to me, but something about my base nature is attracted to it like a moth to a flame.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fedups 10y agoAs you note, this level of self-awareness may not be sufficient, but is probably at least necessary for information sources to provide the kind of value we expect from them. It's still encouraging to see, though.
- lacampbell 10y agoThis makes me wonder more at the pro-Chinese position of a lot of western media, particularly the New York Times. Its fairly telling that Taiwan is most often described as a "renegade province" as opposed to a "peaceful high-income democracy", for example. Having talked to a lot of English speaking, wealthy, educated, overseas Chinese people I am always disturbed at how many of them take communist party positions, despite being able to google "Tiananmen Square". More disturbing when they weren't even born in China.
- scott_s 10y agoI do not get the same impression of "renegade province" when western media talks about Taiwan. I usually get the impression that they're talking about a normal Asian democracy, and then they need to remind the reader about the truly bizarre relationship they have with China. Can you share some examples which demonstrate what you mean?
- mturmon 10y agoGoogling: [site:nytimes.com] [renegade] [province] turns up only things like: "Beijing has maintained that Taiwan is a renegade province..." which is perfectly factual. I do agree with your larger point that a lot of stories in Western media are uncritical of the shortcomings and risks of the Chinese political system.
- paradite 10y agoThat's interesting. Can you recommend me some pro-China Western media? I am having trouble finding one.
- mturmon 10y agoI should be more precise. I'm trying to say that much Western writing is not critical of the decisions the Chinese political system has made about how society is organized there, despite its costs for the country. (E.g., the fast building of roads, trains, and infrastructure; the responsiveness of its electronics industry -- these things have costs for the people of China, but their benefits are very unequally distributed.) I didn't mean to suggest that there is widespread Western cheerleading for China's political system, especially recently as Xi Jinpeng has consolidated power. What I was trying to capture is Western willingness to overlook the costs.
- clairity 10y agoi'd say our political machine in the US has done a great job for the last 35 years at distracting us from the biggest social threat of our times: wealth disparity. instead, the public conversations revolve around terrorism, who uses which bathroom, twitter, celebrities, and even health insurance. if recent political movements (tea party, the 99%) and national elections have taught us anything, it's that this is increasingly on the minds of americans (and seemingly others, but i won't speak for them), yet politicians seem to want to talk about anything but that, lest they lose the financial backing of the economic elite. at its core, this is about fairness, which is one of those fundamental psychological forces we can't and shouldn't ignore. game theory studies show time and again that we are willing to play into lose-lose situations if it means maintaining a semblance of fairness among participants. the trump election seems to be an example of that. the arab spring uprisings seem to be larger, more international examples. we should be relentless about leading our politicians back to the topic of wealth disparity every single time they try to distract us with something else (particularly terrorism, which has killed far fewer people in the last 15 years than a single year of car accidents has, yet we have sacrificed so much monetarily and psychologically trying to battle that phantom).
- maxxxxx 10y agoYou are right. Unfortunately the american electorate is easy to manipulate so they will blame their problems on other groups that are suffering the same problems. Instead of asking why salaries don't go up anymore while the company makes record profits people start attacking each other. The last election was a classical example of distraction. there was almost no discussion of things that would make people's lifes better but instead the propaganda machine talked about e-mail servers, infidelity and "he said, she said".
- jmcgough 10y agoPlenty of people on the left were talking about it, but they live in highly populated states (CA, NY) where their vote counts for a lot less.
- 10y ago
- xapata 10y agobread and circus We've known this for a few millenia.
- general_ai 10y agoWhat is this political drivel doing on HN?
- tunesmith 10y agoIt's a cultural problem. There's always been these two styles of communication - one where you communicate to honestly express your views, and another where you communicate to put across an impression that is useful for your agenda. We're in an age now where the second style is making a huge comeback, from state-sponsored propaganda to social media trolling.
- anonyjoe 10y agopg's own latest post was quickly swept from the front page yesterday by a crew harping on a political analogy unfriendly to Trump. And the top comment is from a 4 day old account that somehow gained 17 karma for the one post. So yes, something seems to be broken. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13414527 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13414527
- chillingeffect 10y agoThere is no doubt that memes and social media have been militarized for propaganda use. This presentation from a consulting agency to many U.S. TLAs and defense contractors outlines the strategies and contains numerous references to DoD work in the area. It gives models, tells what metrics to use, identifies roles, etc. http://robotictechnologyinc.com/index.php/military-memetics http://robotictechnologyinc.com/index.php/military-memetics Either find the PDF halfway down, or just go here: http://robotictechnologyinc.com/images/upload/file/Presentation%20Military%20Memetics%20Tutorial%20Conference%2013%20Dec%2011.pdf http://robotictechnologyinc.com/images/upload/file/Presentat... And here is their 1,680 page compendium of ~100 papers on the subject which they used as references: http://robotictechnologyinc.com/images/upload/file/Memetics%20Compendium%205%20February%2009.pdf http://robotictechnologyinc.com/images/upload/file/Memetics%... Distraction is a tactic, but it's only a single tool in the strategy. It's also relevant when to distract, when to counter, when to ignore, etc.
- DenisM 10y agoThere is something new going on in the social network realm that can undermine trolling efforts as they exist today. Social networks started appearing when tech adoption was relatively scarce. They predate the smartphone revolution. As such they had to bend out of shape to produce as much public or semi-public content in order to attract and engage enough users to sustain the network effects. The direct side effect of this approach is transparency of the discussion. People who disagree would butt heads because the feel the need to defend "their side" in "public". A manipulation agent can assess the current state of discussion as well as the immediate outcome of his actions, so that he can fine-tune his campaigns. Now that the smartphone adoption is basically 100%, it becomes possible to build private social networks without making everything public or semi-public. The ones where content is only posted/shared in a close group and is not observable by trolls. No shares, no reposts, no likes, no "people are talking". Nothing. How would you use Snapchat to assess and manipulate the public opinion? The best you can do is check the hits on your web site. What if you lost even that to some sort of caching? Now you're flying completely blind. Pretty much every popular messenger app has the potential to mutate into an opaque social network. Perhaps many already did.
- buzzybee 10y agoIt correlates with my theory of Endless September someday having an end. The problem of Endless September was growth - too much growth, too quickly. When that stops, and unless we experience an AI personhood event, it has to, because we only have so many people on the planet and so much data they can transmit - the network settles into a place where it can focus on quality instead of sheer scale. In the developed world we are likely already entering this phase, with online access surpassing 80%, and the rest of the world is not that far behind. So then what happens? The business model changes. Social network technologies will re-commoditize and the value will return to communities. Privacy takes a bigger role, as you note. And the world, for better or worse(but probably better), becomes even weirder and harder to assess or manipulate top-down.
- ghempton 10y agoIn the actual paper (http://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/50c.pdf http://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/50c.pdf), the authors say they asked hundreds of Weibo (a chinese social media site) posters the following question: > "I saw your comment, it’s really inspiring, I want to ask, do you have any public opinion guidance management, or online commenting experience?" After tallying up, 19% of the people who post online answered yes.