> This has been demonstrated beyond a shadow of a doubt by xxxxxx, a professor in yyyyyy's Department of Anthropology Anthropology and "shadow of a doubt" neve

> This has been demonstrated beyond a shadow of a doubt by xxxxxx, a professor in yyyyyy's Department of Anthropology Anthropology and "shadow of a doubt" never fit well with me in a sentence. I'd like to hear an independent view on the data. A lot of bone and not many 'human made' scratches with clear evidence of carnivore activity in the cave.