4 ms·
Most ancient people were smart enough (or learned the hard way) to not build their cities on the coast. Most major coastal cities you can think of today -- New
by dheera 10y ago
Most ancient people were smart enough (or learned the hard way) to not build their cities on the coast. Most major coastal cities you can think of today -- New York, Singapore, Shanghai, Tokyo -- have only a couple hundred years of history as a city.
Most cities that were sizably developed in ancient times -- such as Paris, Beijing, Moscow, Rome, Kyoto, Xi'an, London -- were not built on the coast for good reasons. I suspect that the humans in North America would have also avoided living too close to the coast if they were smart.
- knz 10y agoI disagree - we may not have built large settlements by the coast but there are thousands of small towns on the coastlines of the world that were essential in the exploration of the world that drove settlement.
- claystu 10y agoThe location of ancient capitals probably has more to do with the importance of trade and food production than avoiding coastal storms or flooding.
- tarikjn 10y agoNot really, as coastal city can also benefit from fishing, and certain coastal area had maritime trade back in ancient times. But it's not sea level either, my understanding is that the reason why most ancient capitals are built inland is military. Coastal areas are harder to defend from foreign invasions than inland areas, as there is little signal and time to mobilize troops, moreover, martial strategy privileges high ground. Capitals were usually built around a river that connects to the sea, and where that river meets the sea, you can usually find a fortified town which had a military garrison. My guess is that the advent of the airplane bomber has changed the considerations.
- claystu 10y agoDid you mean to reply to me? I ask because your comment appears to be disagreeing with arguments that I never made. My major point was that (1)the coast, by itself, was not a critical factor either pro or con. (2) What appears to matter when it comes to becoming a first rate city is food production and access to trade, be it by road, river, or sea--preferably, all three. Your defense thesis doesn't make sense. If defense really mattered, cities would be built on mountain tops, but they aren't. Instead, cities grow where trade flourishes. They take their lumps, periodically, from invasion, and then rebuild and get back to business. Virtually every major city from the ancient world is still in business, even though the empire that founded it has long since been destroyed. Only when the economic basis of the city gets destroyed, does the city die. That argues for economics trumping military considerations, which, again, was my thesis. Finally, bombers don't appear to have altered this equation one bit. To the best of my knowledge, the major cities from before WWII are still major cities today.
- tarikjn 10y agoYes I meant to reply to you. I think we are confounding flourishing cities and capitals. I was more talking specifically about the later. Most ancient and especially modern capitals (D.C., Canberra, Ottawa etc.) are built inland, but the land mass offer less protection than it did in ancient times, not so much because of bombers actually (land offers ground air defense), but missiles, which were rendered effective at the end of WWII (V-2). Nonetheless it is still a preferred configuration for capitals for the same factors. Coastal cities are just more vulnerable in times of war.
- vkou 10y agoMoscow was founded in the ~11th century. It only became the sprawling metropolis of today because of a series of historical accidents, that had more to do with who won what war, then its superior location.