3 ms·
What federated / decentralized protocols have been actual successes? For what protocols can I set up my own server in my house or in some cloud service, and hav
by geofft 10y ago
What federated / decentralized protocols have been actual successes? For what protocols can I set up my own server in my house or in some cloud service, and have a comparable experience to using a major provider's service (modulo scalability and personal sysadmin effort)?
I'm worried that the only ones seem to be email and the web, both of which came into existence when the internet was small and academic and it was natural for universities to decentralize. And running email on your own is getting increasingly hard because of spam and IP reputation. (We seem to have more-or-less won the war on spam, but at the cost of making email much less decentralized than it used to be.)
There's a mention of BitTorrent elsewhere in these comments, and there might be an argument for Bitcoin. But even for IRC, people tend not to run their own servers (although they could); there are a very small number of IRC networks, run by random people.
I would love to see a decentralized and federated team chat app along the lines of Slack or Discord, but I'm having trouble believing that such a thing would have a chance of success in a post-1995 internet.
- techphys_91 10y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, but https://riot.im/ https://riot.im/ seems to fit the description of a decentralised and federated team chat app.
- bigbugbag 10y ago> running email on your own is getting increasingly hard because of spam and IP reputation. Are you sure ? https://mailinabox.email/ https://mailinabox.email/
- geofft 10y agoI am not sure, but that page doesn't talk about deliverability at all, as far as I can see. Is it generally true that spawning a mail server on a random cloud instance will work for deliverability? I would have assumed that any given cloud IP has a nonzero chance of having been used by a spammer in the past. (Or, in other words, if this does work, why do people who have small- to medium-scale deliverability needs use a dedicated email-sending provider instead of just using a t2.nano running an AMI with Postfix?)