4 ms·
> Is Signal's system (not user data) fully open and transparent, end-to-end? I believe that it is not transparent in the usual sense, because the server-side c
by geofft 10y ago
> Is Signal's system (not user data) fully open and transparent, end-to-end?
I believe that it is not transparent in the usual sense, because the server-side component is has no source available, but also that it does not need to be transparent in a cryptographic sense: the amount of information known by the Signal servers is minimal, and doesn't include messages, contact graphs, or even which users are communicating with each other. It does include what users they have and what phone numbers, and when they log in / where from: I assume they could also learn whether someone is using Signal at a given time and how much (from bytes transferred) but nothing more interesting about the conversation. I believe the use of Google Cloud Messaging is the same way.
I haven't looked into the protocol myself and I'm not sure if all of this is true. In particular, while OWS says they don't have any "records" of who a user is communicating with (https://whispersystems.org/bigbrother/eastern-virginia-grand-jury/ https://whispersystems.org/bigbrother/eastern-virginia-grand...), I'm not actually sure if this means they're just not logging it, and a system could be built to record this.