4 ms·
In this case it worked, but what are the false positive rate? Roughly 412 million images was scanned in this case. How many scans will this be per year if used
by belorn 10y ago
In this case it worked, but what are the false positive rate? Roughly 412 million images was scanned in this case. How many scans will this be per year if used on all known criminals that goes on the run? What happens in the case of a false positive, and at what rate will this cause major impact on an innocent (ie, lost time to fight the false accusation, lost jobs/relationships, swat team charging in with guns into someones home, and so on). Is there a cost-benefit analyze that is favorable to run this kind of biometric system over the more traditional hire-more-investigators approach to solving more cases? If it was cost-effective, would it still be so if the state provided a fair compensation to every harmed innocent?
Its not a knee-jerk reaction, but plain experience from reading the answer to such question that studies have done on past biometric, data retention and surveillance systems. A common theme that keep getting repeated are generally high cost, high false positive rates, and low results.
- Johnny555 10y agoAnd how does one defend themselves after being falsely identified? I'm sure there's more that one guy that lived in Indiana 17 years ago that looked kinda similar to what that guy looked like then. Having the FBI come into your workplace and arrest you is bad for your career whether you're guilty or not. I remember when I was doing online dating -- I had the same name, had lived in the same area, and was about the same age as the brother of a serial killer that was quoted prominently in the news. I told new matches that when they googled me, that that guy was not me. Not sure how to do convince my boss that when the FBI leads me out of the office in handcuffs that it's just a case of mistaken identity.
- philipkglass 10y agoPeople have been identifying wanted criminals from photographs for a long time. Sometimes humans identify correctly but often they are incorrect. I would hope that there is a less drastic/foolish procedure than "FBI handcuffs person at work, investigates later" every time that someone thinks their new neighbor looks like a criminal on a poster and phones in a tip. Just substitute "algorithm phones in a tip" for "neighbor phones in a tip." https://www.usmarshals.gov/investigations/most_wanted/ https://www.usmarshals.gov/investigations/most_wanted/
- notahacker 10y agoHigh false positive rates are the one genuine concern, but requiring juries to be instructed about false positives (and ruling frankly misleading statements about probability of an individual match being correct inadmissible) and investigating for corroborating/confounding evidence seems like a more fruitful approach than resisting the technology. It's not like other forms of police work don't involve many people inconvenienced by being incorrectly dragged into criminal cases and sometimes put on trial. I doubt the false positive rate from biometrics etc is worse than any other method of criminal investigation, and it's not to incorrectly-identified suspects' disadvantage that they're further removed from the crime than suspects incorrectly identified via more traditional investigative work.