3 ms·
Short of such draconian consequences it's hard to find a system of incentives that encourage good thinking in the long run. Decision markets (ala Robin Hanson'
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Short of such draconian consequences it's hard to find a system of incentives that encourage good thinking in the long run.
Decision markets (ala Robin Hanson's futarchy) attempt to do this. In short: we vote on our goals. We then bet on whether Policy X or Policy Y achieves this goal. We select the policy with the highest odds of success (say X). Then anyone who bet on Policy Y gets their money refunded, and anyone who favored Policy X loses money if it doesn't work. Thus, anyone who favors bad policy loses all their money.
The main drawback to such a market is that it might not be deep enough; if one bets 1 million dollars on policy "transfer 2 million dollars to me" and causes that policy to be enacted, they lose money on their bets but still make out like a bandit.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mnemonicsloth 17y agobets 1 million dollars on policy "transfer 2 million dollars to me" and causes that policy to be enacted, they lose money on their bets but still make out like a bandit. This glosses over the difference between prediction markets (markets for bets on outcomes) and futarchy (voting on results we want and automatically enacting the policies prediction markets endorse to achieve those results). Also, wouldn't a market thin enough to be gamed by interested parties attract investors like a stock trading at less than 1x earnings?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIt's very true that irrational bettors actually attract speculators (who are able to take their money). So it might be the case that interested parties can't push decision markets too far. I.e., the cost of influencing "policy give me 2 million bucks" might be 3 million dollars. Robin Hanson certainly believes this is true, but Mencius Moldbug believes he has found a real world case where it isn't. I don't understand the issue well enough to offer an informed opinion. http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2010/02/pipe-shorting-and-professor-hansons.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2010/02/pipe-sh...