3 ms·
I think the writer gives too much credit to mathematicians and too little to politicians. Politics doesn't look the way it looks because politicians are too st
by dagw 17y ago
I think the writer gives too much credit to mathematicians and too little to politicians. Politics doesn't look the way it looks because politicians are too stupid to understand your counterargument. I'm sure most politicians are well aware of the logical inconsistencies or fallacies in their argument, but more importantly they realize that their arguments and talking points are a means to an end and not an end in themselves and you don't get bonus points for correctness.
- yequalsx 17y agoI agree for the most part but some of them really are dumb. It's power, the limelight, and a ego boost that some of them crave and thus are easily manipulated. Definitely, though, it's true that they make bad arguments because it gets them to their goal. It's not because they don't know that the argument is bad, it's because they know the viewing public largely doesn't know this.
- samd 17y agoI can't recommend enough that people watch The Wire. It is especially illuminating on the subject of why politicians and bureaucrats do what they do.
- thebigshane 17y agoI haven't seen The Wire, but I have achieved similar insight from The West Wing. Would anybody agree to West Wing's accuracy (at least relatively) to American political reality?
- chasingsparks 17y agoI live in DC. I briefly worked for a think tank whereby I was exposed to a lot of politicians. In general, those that rise are smart (shocker). They manipulate as a means to an end, thinking themselves justified. Unfortunately, everyone is using the same means (i.e. manipulation) leading to some pretty weird systems. Most politicians then fall victim to pursuing their ends relentlessly, even if the landscape has changed so much that an unbiased observer could see it is no longer of value. To be fair, this happens to most ambitious people at some point. The difference being that the non-politician (e.g. entrepreneur) who becomes blind to material changes fails locally in his pursuit while the politician fails nationally.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoThis is true, but not the whole story. Many, if not most, political decisions are not determined based on logic alone, but at least partly on values. Because of this, it's possible for two different, rational people to both reason correctly from the same data yet arrive at different conclusions. For example, amongst economists there is no question that outsourcing work or production overseas is a net benefit to the economy. If this were the entire discussion, then we'd all go home now happy. However, there is an additional level of argument that can only be addressed through one's moral system and values, which differs from person to person. Some people would say that although this outsourcing does help society as a whole, it also harms a small number of people whose jobs go overseas, and that in recompense for this benefit to the rest of us, we owe the now-unemployed some help. The truth of that, and the size of any aid that it implies, is not something we can get to through purely rational argument.
- anigbrowl 17y agoI partly agree, but this, like the original article, assumes that politicians act as free agents once elected - that is, vote according only to their own best analysis of the situation. However, most political calculus is colored heavily by the question of how it will play with voters via the media. To take your outsourcing example, it is indeed the case that outsourcing is likely to leave everyone better off overall, and individual negative effects could be mitigated with careful planning. But if a large part of your electorate believes in the lump of labor fallacy, and your opponent's campaign team is happy to perpetuate this mistaken belief while dismissing your attempts to foster local economic alternatives as pork-barrel spending, then the arguments in your re-election campaign are rapidly headed for lowest-common-denominator territory. I made a resolution this past new year to give up my hobby of arguing politics on the internet and have (mostly) stuck with it, by the simple expedient of blocking a few websites whose signal-noise ratio had long since gone to the dogs. I have no idea how politicians deal with the daily tide of incoming phone calls, emails, faxes and so on, beyond hiring thick-skinned secretarial staff. Not that I'm shedding tears for the political class, who in many cases choose to concentrate on the game at the expense of the results, but it's kind of amazing that anything gets done. I don't think it's a problem of scale (eg the size of the federal government); I see the exact same problems at the municipal level.