3 ms·
Regardless of whether or not the original post was rude is no excuse for a rude answer. Kindness begets kindness, patience begets patience. We have a duty to no
by moron4hire 17y ago
Regardless of whether or not the original post was rude is no excuse for a rude answer. Kindness begets kindness, patience begets patience. We have a duty to not escalate stuff like this into shit-storms. If the kid didn't post correctly, then we should answer by asking the right questions to guide him to the correct question. If you can't do that, then just move along, you don't need to post.
I remember being that kid. Well, not quite so bad that I literally wanted someone to write code for me, but I'm sure someone thought my poorly worded questions were asking people to write code for me. How many kids are we scaring away because we're being assholes to them?
- DCoder 17y agoThere's just so many times you can direct people to http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html without losing your sanity. I spent several years trying to help people on a specific topic and eventually gave up because the stream of people who haven't put their brain to use before asking was reaching 90%. And that's on a niche topic, I don't even want to know how much more noise common topics get, and I have great respect for people like Heathfield for not giving up.
- Silhouette 17y ago> Regardless of whether or not the original post was rude is no excuse for a rude answer. The answer wasn't rude, it was just unhelpful. For those not familiar with the culture on comp.lang.c and the various related C and C++ groups, it is very simple: people will generally be helpful in dealing with homework questions as long as the asker has made a genuine effort. On the other hand, anyone who just reposts homework verbatim with no effort whatsoever to solve the problem first is likely to find themselves given a very clever answer that is technically correct but clearly completely implausible for a beginner, thus making it very obvious to the teacher that the person is cheating on their homework. I recall a similar example where someone asked how to work out factorials in C++, and was presented with a highly efficient answer... because it used template metaprogramming and generated that answer at compile time. This was certainly clear in the related FAQs last time I checked, so anyone who asks a homework question without making any effort to solve it themselves is not only lazy but also incapable of following basic netiquette. I doubt you'd find many regular posters on those groups who had much sympathy, even though some of those same posters give up a great deal of time to help those who are making a genuine effort to improve.
- foldr 17y ago>The answer wasn't rude, it was just unhelpful. Being deliberately unhelpful is rude.
- moron4hire 17y agoSo is your time valuable or not? Is your time is too valuable to waste on people who don't put in a genuine effort, or is it not valuable enough that posting an unhelpful answer isn't a waste of effort? That's my point, it's easier for you to just ignore the bad poster. And yes, a deliberately unhelpful answer is rude.
- jerf 17y agoHave you ever hung out on a comp.lang.X site being helpful to people? I acknowledge your description of the POV of the questioner, but from the POV of someone who spends significant time helping out people who have (ahem) "real" problems, see if you're still so polite after your 200th "please solve my homework problem!" post. To whatever riposte you might be planning, I would point out that I'm not talking about theory, either. Yeah, sure, everyone deserves care and love and ponies. I'm talking about, in practice, would you still be so caring and loving and pony-dispensing after hundreds of these things? If so, you're better than most. (Too much better for me to believe in, in fact.)