6 ms·
It is not the EU telling these countries what to do. It is other EU countries telling other EU countries what to do, just because they have more votes. What i
by stale2002 10y ago
It is not the EU telling these countries what to do. It is other EU countries telling other EU countries what to do, just because they have more votes.
What if one EU country wants to do something else? Can't different EU countries just choose to do their own thing, and be ruled by their OWN population, instead of people in Germany deciding what happens to people in Poland?
If greece doesn't want to deal with these immigrants then THEY should chose to close their own borders.
Self determination is the fundamental issue at stake here.
The EU IS telling countries what to do! People in Germany are deciding what happens to people in Poland!
- gambiting 10y agoUgh. No, it's like a group of people deciding to do something together. Sometimes you don't like what the group is doing,but it's usually better to be in it than outside of it. I personally would love for EU to unite even further,just call it United States of Europe and stop saying that it's German people telling Polish people what to do or vice versa - it doesn't matter, or at least I wish it didn't. And I'm sure you know very well that "closing borders" wouldn't do a thing when immigrants arrive via boats and land on your beaches asking for asylum. You just can't send people back to active war zones, and that has nothing to do with EU regulations.
- stale2002 10y ago"it doesn't matter, or at least I wish it didn't." It doesn't matter to you, but I am sure it matters a whole lot to the people of Poland (but fuck them, I guess?). Apparently they've changed their mind about this deal, and just want to be left alone. The EU isn't a suicide pact. People can and will change their mind, and will change the deal along with it. "You just can't send people back to active war zones, and that has nothing to do with EU regulations." Then send them to Germany or Sweden. They love the refugees! It is a win win situation. If they really do believe all the things that they say, then it should be no problem, right?
- artursapek 10y ago> They love the refugees! I think you're probably being sarcastic, but after the latest semi truck incident at the holiday market there were reportedly protests outside of Merkel's office. The right wing is gaining traction. I'd be surprised if she is still in power in 3 years.
- gambiting 10y ago>>It doesn't matter to you, but I am sure it matters a whole lot to the people of Poland (but fuck them, I guess?). Well, I am Polish, and "a whole lot of people in Poland" want things that I absolutely disagree with(prohibition of gay marriage, abortion, they want the church to meddle with politics etc etc). So while I wouldn't say "fuck them", I would say that I disagree with their opinion strongly. >>Then send them to Germany or Sweden. They love the refugees! There's no need to go from one extreme to another. Basically the options are: 1) Send them back where they came from 2) Try to house them where they arrive 3) Try to distribute them around the EU evenly so that the burden on each country is minimal Option 1 is probably what most people would want, but that doesn't make it feasible. Even if we assume that we know exactly where they are from, which is not always true, we could probably send back people to countries which are not torn by war. But that still leaves you with people who are genuienly fleeing war, and if you are advocating sending them back there, then well....I think we can finish the discussion here. Second option is terrible, because neither Italy nor Greece have the capacity to handle this many immigrants. The best they(or anyone) could do is built a huge camp for them, but as you can imagine that would be a distaster very quickly, if done at that scale. Option number 3 evokes a lot of negative emotions, but unless someone comes up with a better solution, it seems like the best way to go.