3 ms·
1. the hair on fire alarmism over imagined issues distracts from some very real issues. 2. some of those very real issues have very real solutions, but people
by tedunangst 10y ago
1. the hair on fire alarmism over imagined issues distracts from some very real issues.
2. some of those very real issues have very real solutions, but people still cry bloody murder because those solutions don't solve every imagined problem.
3. Exaggerating the scope of the problem conveys a sense of helplessness. What purpose is served by making people needlessly afraid? There's a point at which the harm caused by surveillance panic exceeds the harm caused by surveillance.
4. the hysteria results in people making stupid choices regarding email, messaging, etc. like "I can't trust the companies I know, so I'm going to trust companies I don't know". That's ridiculous. Or the fact that while Comcast may inject some janky notifications on web pages I visit, it's not straightup malware like rogue tor exit nodes inject.
5. It becomes impossible for anybody to actually discuss what's happening when every little molehill is a backdoor, or rootkit, or malware, or existential threat to cyber existence.
- tptacek 10y agoI'd also add that none of us should need to apologize for civil, good-faith discussion on HN.
- revelation 10y agoThis obsession with comparatives is pointless if we don't know the scope.