4 ms·
Why President Obama Can't Pardon Edward Snowden
- RichardHeart 10y agoHe should have said "Won't" instead of "Can't." tldr; Whether Snowden’s theft was an idealistic attempt to right a wrong, a narcissistic drive to obtain personal recognition, an attempt to weaken the foundations of the surveillance infrastructure in which he worked, or all of the above, by the time he stepped off that Aeroflot jet in Moscow, it had evolved, intentionally or not, into something much simpler and far less admirable. He was disclosing vital national secrets to a foreign power. Conjectures about Snowden’s motives matter less than the undeniable fact that he was greatly assisted in his endeavors by powerful enemies of the United States." I bet if you had a program where whistle blowers were honored instead of destroyed internally, you'd have less exfiltration of data, and less external whistle blowing. The 4th amendment has been getting curb stomped for quite a while now, I'm curious as to when it'll be declared deceased. You currently have no expectation of privacy at a border, or too close to a border, or with any data at your phone carrier, or isp, or email provider, so really where does this "persons, houses, papers, and effects," really exist anymore? Hell, even if you think the 5th amendment protects you from being coerced with prison into telling your passwords, it often doesn't. Maybe I'm missing something, and the 4th amendment is doing a great job somewhere, if it is I could use a reminder, I'm getting jaded.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoA president can pardon anyone from any crime for any reason, or no reason at all... I thought it was only federal crimes that can be pardoned, no?
- netsharc 10y agoAnd I thought the pardoned person had to have been convicted of the crime. Except if it's Nixon...
- LargeWu 10y agoWell, that's called a blanket pardon, and the fact that it was granted to Nixon establishes it as precedent.
- Spooky23 10y agoI believe that pardons for state crimes can "forgive" someone federally and release them from Federal sanction. The power is vaguely defined and is absolute. Short of being outside the lines enough to justify impeachment, it can probably mean whatever a president wants it to.
- maehwasu 10y agoThe author's argument boils down to: 1. Snowden didn't come back to the US, so he must be a traitor (rather than a non-idiot who knew exactly what had happened to Chelsea Manning). 2. Putin allowed him to come when the passport had been cancelled, so Snowden must have agreed to sell Russia state secrets. This feels very much like a deep state smear job, especially given the weirdly adulatory photo of Obama.
- blueprint 10y agoYes, and the blatant and frequent language and tone stating as if it's a foregone conclusion that his actions constituted crimes while providing such insubstantial arguments. It's almost insulting.
- skwirl 10y agoThe author didn't say or imply either of those things.
- asveikau 10y agoBut as the article points out, Putin is not a warm, fuzzy, lovingly altruistic person. He wouldn't do favors if he didn't get something in return. I always assumed it was more PR reasons, rather than anything Snowden knows. How can the US accuse the Russian Federation of human rights abuses or lack of individual freedoms if they have a walking, talking example of a citizen who cannot go home to the US but lives free in Russia? It's farcical, as Putin's Russia is less free than the US, but it does shut down debate. And in a slight change of topic, I have been really shocked in the last 6 months how willing ordinary Americans are to defend Putin in political discussion. Something is working over there.
- MichaelBurge 10y ago> And in a slight change of topic, I have been really shocked in the last 6 months how willing ordinary Americans are to defend Putin in political discussion. Something is working over there. Stefan Molyneux just did a video on McCarthy's attempt to root out Russian infiltration, that you might find interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wljpYZ8wejA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wljpYZ8wejA I don't have anything against Putin; he seems like an effective leader, though Russia has different values than the US. Though, the history makes for a good conspiracy story: Maybe McCarthy's spies are still there!
- andrewclunn 10y agoNot convincing. Really tried to read with an open mind, but there was literally no new info here, just a narrative spin.
- qubex 10y ago”Projective speculation”
- CPLX 10y agoI read this entire thing through and it's literally like vapor, there's nothing to it whatsoever that supports it's headline, and no counter narrative that upends the basic story Snowden and his journalist contacts have laid out. I assume this writer is now owed a favor by his buddies at the NSA who he worked with on this story.
- imjustsaying 10y agoWhy President Obama Can't Pardon Edward Snowden: because they're not on the same team. Snowden sacrificed a cushy job in Hawaii and risked life in prison because he's a hopeless romantic True Believer in the American style philosophy of freedom.
- xutopia 10y agoThe only thing he shows is that Snowden was premeditated. We already knew that.
- na85 10y agoCharacter assassination. So rife with innuendo, appeals to emotion and straw men and so utterly devoid of fact that I don't know where to begin.
- firmgently 10y ago"my book, How America Lost Its Secrets: Snowden, the Man and the Theft.".. well that sounds balanced
- JackC 10y agoOne new allegation (as far as I know) in this article is this: "Obama also knows that NSA documents Snowden copied and removed but did not give to those journalists in Hong Kong were used to embarrass America’s allies in NATO well after he arrived in Moscow. For example, the explosive revelation that the NSA targeted the cellphone of German Chancellor Angela Merkel was released in September [2013]. In June 2015, NSA documents stolen by Snowden on WikiLeaks caused further trouble by revealing that the phones of three presidents of France—Jacques Chirac, Nicolas Sarkozy and François Hollande—had also been targeted. These embarrassing revelations—made long after Snowden claimed he had no more documents—put Obama in a very bad spot with America’s European allies." It's an important part of Snowden's history that he gave all the documents he had to Glenn Greenwald, and didn't keep access himself. Bruce Schneier believes that Snowden was not the source of the September 2013 leak,[1] and I can't find anyone (before this article) even suggesting that Snowden was the source of the June 2015 leak. There's no source for the claim in this article, other than "Obama knows." So that seems significant if true, but it's a pretty nasty smear if not -- I hope it doesn't stand as an unsourced rumor. [1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/the_us_intellig.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/the_us_intell...
- johnalamos 10y ago((Stein)) Every single time
- sctb 10y agoThis account has been posting mostly uncivil or unsubstantive comments. Please stop and (re-)read the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html