6 ms·
This article presents a very inaccurate view of the realist approach. The universe does not "split" when you make a measurement. The measurement problem is a
by lisper 10y ago
This article presents a very inaccurate view of the realist approach. The universe does not "split" when you make a measurement.
The measurement problem is a solved problem. The solution is that measurement and entanglement are the same physical phenomenon. Measurement is just entanglement extended to a macroscopic system through a process called "decoherence". The net result is that, when you do the math, you recover classical behavior by taking "slices" of the wave function (the mathematical operation is called a "trace"). This has been known for decades now, and provides a coherent and easy-to-understand picture of what is "really" going on. It is astonishing to me that the physics community still bifurcates into two camps: those who think this is common knowledge, and those who are completely unaware of it (or think it's a crazy idea).
References:
http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc (The same content in a video)
http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/09/are-parallel-universes-real.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/09/are-parallel-universes-re...
http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...
- iheartmemcache 10y agoWell the Copenhagen interpretation traditionally requires the act of an 'observer'. I.e., you are not allowed to perform that act of summation on the set of orthonormal vectors in N dimensional Hilbert spaces until an "observer" observes. (That's where that stupid cat came into play and the 'uncertainty' of it being both dead and alive simultaneously until it's 'observed'.) Until this discrete event occurs, the wave function doesn't "collapse" and we're just living in statistical la-la land. The disagreement lies in "I can mathematically apply the trace function, I'm just not quite sure when". Alternatively, according to the Everett interpretation (to which I subscribe, and to which you seem to as well) quite a few reputed physicists do believe that the universe "splits" (though not in an actual literal sense, there's nothing ripping the universe physically in two) every time an "observation" occurs and there are lots and lots of occurring simultaneously taken from various frames of reference. This actually makes a lot of sense. Let Sean Carroll https://youtu.be/ZacggH9wB7Y https://youtu.be/ZacggH9wB7Y convince (the plural) you.
- lisper 10y agoThe wave function never collapses. This is easily demonstrated with a simple thought experiment that is described in the first two references that I link to.
- n4r9 10y ago> The measurement problem is a solved problem. I think this is overselling it slightly. Yes, Everettian style interpretations have helped to shed insight into the reality of the quantum state. Yes, decoherence has helped us to understand physical systems and their interactions with the environment. But if the measurement problem was solved there wouldn't continue to be a swathe of literature on the measurement problem by respected quantum theorists. There are some very good reasons for doubting the validity of many world interpretations. We don't have much of a consensus on what's "really" going on, and I don't believe we will for quite some time.
- tim333 10y agoIndeed it's not that solved. A big problem is as Weinberg puts it >Several attempts following the realist approach have come close to deducing rules like the Born rule that we know work well experimentally, but I think without final success. which is kind of the heart of things.
- lisper 10y agoJust because Steven Weinberg is unaware of or does not accept the solution does not mean that the problem is not in fact solved.
- tim333 10y agoI don't think that's been solved either or most physicists for that matter. I've read some of the attempts and they are not terrible good. I don't think Ron Garret even touched on the Born rule, Everett of many worlds just hand waves and assumes it. The attempts I've seen are basically of the form that if the rule was different from the probability equaling the absolute amplitude squared then reality wouldn't come out as we find, so it must be so, which is not much of an explanation in my book.
- lisper 10y agoFYI, I am Ron Garret. It's true that I don't talk about the Born rule or multiple worlds in the paper, but I do talk about multiple worlds in the video (at the end, during the Q&A) and in the blog posts I linked to above. As for the Born rule, what kind of an explanation are you hoping for? Some things can't be explained beyond, "That's just how it is." For example, why do the fundamental physical constants have the values that they have? Maybe this will help: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406241 http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html
- opaque 10y agoDecoherence is an extremely useful and elegant mechanism for understanding quantum systems, but unfortunately it doesn't solve the measurement problem. At least not to the satisfaction of most practising physicists. The entanglement and trace operation does produce classical probabilities in the observed sub-system. However, it requires you to make a pretty arbitrary division between the observed system and the wider environment. Why is everything not just entangled with everything else up and up the chain until the entire universe is in superposition? The problem of where the quantum world ends and the classical world begins is still unanswered. This is one of the greatest open questions in physics, likely requiring a unification of general relativity and quantum mechanics before it's resolved.
- beevai142 10y agoThis is correct. As it is usually applied in practice in the literature, the measurement device decoheres the quantum system and becomes entangled with it --- and at the end of the calculation, Copenhagen interpretation is applied on the measurement device. It works fine in practice, but in the end it is philosophically just the Copenhagen interpretation. If something is not accepted by the wider physics community, it's very likely the correctness of the thing in question is not that clear.
- lisper 10y ago> in the end it is philosophically just the Copenhagen interpretation No, it isn't. The wave function never collapses. This is easily demonstrated with a simple thought experiment which is described in the first two references that I link to.
- FrostyElsa 10y agoPeople are so dumbfounded by the Everettian interpretation. It may take more time (with Quantum computing help) to prove that the wave function indeed never collapses and that there are infinite number of probabilistic worlds in actual existence. Hello graveyardigans.
- 10y ago
- gaze 10y agoThis is going in circles. You still need to put in Born's rule by hand somewhere. If you can explain the origin of Born's rule we'll have gotten somewhere. I also don't understand why you call a trace a slice. It's an ensemble average. Try deriving the density matrix formalism by coupling a small system to some collection of ancillae and you'll see that it doesn't really add anything. The trace is just convenient notation for the operator sandwich of closed quantum systems... it's just that your closed system is now an open system tensored with a bath.
- lisper 10y ago> You still need to put in Born's rule by hand somewhere I'm not sure what you mean by "putting Born's rule in by hand". We're talking about interpretations here. Born's rule is just an empirical fact. Do you mean that I need to explain why the probabilities are the square of the amplitude? That's kind of like asking me to explain why the speed of light has the value that it has. It doesn't have an explanation. It's just part of the Way Things Are. But I can make the following heuristic arguments: 1. Outcomes are probabilistic because this is the only way that classical behavior can emerge from the wave function, and without classical behavior you can't copy information, and without copying information you can't have discussions like the one we're having. It's an anthropomorphic argument (actually it's a info-pomomorphic argument :-) 2. The probabilities are the square of the amplitude because that is how you get a useful mathematical model of reality. It is simply an empirical fact that destructive interference happens, so if you want to build a mathematical model of that you need something that can take on negative values. You can't have negative probabilities in classical reality, so the underlying reality must be something other than classical probabilities. The square root of the probability is just the simplest mathematical model that explains the observations. Maybe this will help: the technical paper that my position is based on is here: https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002v2.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002v2.pdf
- akvadrako 10y agoThere are a few ways to derive the Born rule within WMI. None are perfect but their assumptions are fairly reasonable and most importantly the handling of probability is better defined than in classical mechanics or Copenhagen, so it's not a reason to discount the theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation#Probability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation#Pro...