42 ms·
I applaud the OP's bravery, but after a long, long time in the telco business and having seen many attempts from multiple platforms towards gaining a foothold (
by rcarmo 10y ago
I applaud the OP's bravery, but after a long, long time in the telco business and having seen many attempts from multiple platforms towards gaining a foothold (Symbian, Maemo, LiMo - including Vodafone's own version - Bada, etc.), I have to point out that Ubuntu Phone, despite the vision and values behind it, is at a massively overwhelming disadvantage in terms of both telco appeal (what I and my former colleagues still in the device procurement part of the telco business have seen so far has no compelling advantage over Android) and ecosystem.
Even if selling off-telco worked, the one problem I see is the lack of that ecosystem, or a way to bootstrap it, because if it ran Android apps (and therefore fracture the user experience) that would not ensure developer adoption... And most people only want a "good enough" phone that lets them run apps and a few games, which further compounds the problem -- the value of Ubuntu Phone Just isn't apparent to them, which is sad.
- giancarlostoro 10y agoI think the biggest thing that could probably help the Ubuntu Phone is an approachable development environment. If the road to developing apps for a phone is short enough, that people on their weekend make apps for it, it will expand rapidly with apps. This requires great tooling, and documentation. Potentially even adoption of a programming language that either comes with a powerful SDK or is tailored from the ground up for this purpose, or forked. We've seen this type of boom with Go. Go has a LOT of out of the box functionality, and Python does too, it is what makes people stick to them once they like them in my opinion. However, tooling and documentation are key. I know Ubuntu has Ubuntu Make, but it still has a long way to go. If they can make a great development ecosystem, they can bring in a number of developers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- simonh 10y agoThey should be targeting OEMs and telcos as their primary customers and a first class dev environment is key to that. The reason Android AOSP is so widely available is it's free, is trivial to port to new hardware and is easy to customise. Since ORMS and telcos are the gatekeepers to anything reaching customers, appealing to them has to come first. Fail to attract them and it doesn't matter how popular you might have been with customers, because they'll never even get to see your product.
- epmaybe 10y agoI'm not sure that this holds true in today's ecosystem. Yes, developers may come to the platform, but the big companies won't come unless the consumers come to the platform. And consumers won't come unless Facebook, Snapchat, etc show up.
- seabrookmx 10y agoCurious why you say Go comes with a lot out of the box. Compared to Python or Java I find it pretty lacking. And even more so when you include 3rd party libraries and the fact that Go has no package manager ala. pip or Ivy. Android Studio is a pretty mature well documented way to make apps so if anyone is truly determined and has some programming experience, making a simple Android app in a weekend is doable. I've heard (but don't know personally) that the iOS toolchain is even easier to use. That all aside, nobody will WANT to spend their weekend making Ubuntu apps when nobody has a phone to run them.
- mixedCase 10y ago> and the fact that Go has no package manager ala. pip or Ivy. A featureful Go package manager a la Cargo or NPM is coming. A not-so basic package manager is baked into the language and its official tooling. It just behaves like a Unix application, so instead of "pip uninstall package" you run "rm -rf $GOPATH/src/github.com/author/package" (or do it in your app's vendor directory, instead of using a virtualenv).
- mixedCase 10y ago>We've seen this type of boom with Go. Canonical was in fact funding development of go-qml, with the Ubuntu phone in mind. It has unfortunately broken over time, although a fork exists maintained by the limetext developers. There is a Qt (and QML) binding library at github.com/therecipe/qt which works, but is far less simple.
- digi_owl 10y ago> Symbian Err?