4 ms·
You're welcome to move to a non taxation government, or just to one where it is barely enforced
by raverbashing 10y ago
You're welcome to move to a non taxation government, or just to one where it is barely enforced
- pitaj 10y agoYou're welcome to move to North Korea if you love the state so much. Yeah, it's not really a valid argument, is it.
- DannyBee 10y agoActually, it is. You choose to live in a country that has a constitution. You abide by that constitution. Like any sane government, you can change that constitution. That's "consent of the governed". But saying "things that people have consented to in the past, that i have not, are not binding upon me, and therefore taxation is theft" makes no sense. The world existed before you were born. You can leave the country at any time.
- pitaj 10y agoI didn't choose to be born in this country. I never gave my consent. > You can leave the country at any time. You seem pretty confident. But you're wrong. There are countless barriers to exit, especially if you are poor. Even if I could leave, there is no viable stateless territory on which I can live.
- DannyBee 10y ago"I didn't choose to be born in this country. I never gave my consent. " Talk to your parents, and their parents, and their parents, who did. Like i said, this is pretty much only a valid argument until age of majority. But note: even before then, you are taking advantage of the contract, which is the essence of implied consent in every legal system. ". There are countless barriers to exit, especially if you are poor." There literally are not. You may walk, all the way to a border, and exit, as many people have. You may not be accepted elsewhere, nor may you have a good time, but that is different, and changes nothing about consent. (remember that document you didn't consent to, that's the thing that tries to make it so you might have a good time here) "Even if I could leave, there is no viable stateless territory on which I can live. " Nor does this change anything about consent either. The fact that you want something does not mean that your inability to get it easily changes anything. Nothing has ever been easy. You want a viable stateless territory, go make one, by force if necessary. Heck, you are complaining about lack of consent, go get people to consent to one. Suck it up. Nothing in the above is a valid argument about you consenting or not, just an argument that "if i don't consent, life is tough." To which the answer is: Yes, yes it is. That's why we created governments in the first place.
- pitaj 10y agoParents can't consent for their children.
- DannyBee 10y agoNo human society in the history of human society has claimed this, because it's ridiculously stupid. If you want to claim this, okay. Great, parents can't consent for their children. Since the document you don't consent to is the only thing that makes it illegal for me to murder you, ..., it's now okay to go out and murder every child, because they haven't explicitly consented. Instead, of course, we discover that parents in fact, sanely consent for children until those children are capable of consenting or not consenting for themselves. We also discover the concept of implied consent, whereby people using the benefits of a contract have also consented to the burdens.
- pitaj 10y agoNo. It's not okay, because the children did not consent to be murdered. Can a parent consent for the child to have sex? Of course not. A parent can't sign their child's life into debt. Parents can not consent for their children, especially when that consent entails being conscripted into military service, taxed, and being put in prison for possessing a plant.
- sokoloff 10y ago> A parent can't sign their child's life into debt. Student loans aren't actually very far away from that. (Not everyone taking out a student loan is over 18 or the local age of majority, which I realize that you haven't personally consented to what that age of majority should be.)
- tptacek 10y agoYou should re-read Hobbes. Outside the social contract we live in the natural state of man, where our rights are to do whatever we think necessary to ensure our well-being, no matter the consequences to anyone else. Without a state, from where do you derive the right not to be murdered? The strength of your own limbs, and little else.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoMany people are actually working towards the goal of a non-taxation (or "private") government to reach an "Anarcho-Capitalist" society. Many of the original proponents of bitcoin are following a path called "Agorism", which is a method to reach this goal by engaging in "grey" market activities such as buying and selling goods through a non-state-managed currency without paying taxes, to achieve a peaceful revolution, without having to physically move.
- lngnmn 10y agoYou perhaps should google out the meaning of the world utopia... and wishful thinking.
- icebraining 10y ago“A map of the world that does not include Utopia is not worth even glancing at, for it leaves out the one country at which Humanity is always landing. And when Humanity lands there, it looks out, and, seeing a better country, sets sail. Progress is the realisation of Utopias.”
- lacampbell 10y agoYou could say that in response to literally anything a government does. You're welcome to move to a non spying government, you're welcome to move to a non prohibitionist government, you're welcome to move to a non police brutality government, etc etc. Are you are arguing that staying in a geographical area constitutes consent for whatever the state in control of it does?
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoUsing raverbashing's logic, it sounds like he is saying every American resident "consents" to everything that Bush/Obama has done and everything that Trump will do...
- raverbashing 10y ago> Are you are arguing that staying in a geographical area constitutes consent for whatever the state in control of it does? No I'm saying that without the government you wouldn't be making this comment on the internet, in English, or even have had a roof over your head.
- sneak 10y agoThe humans that comprise the current US government had no part in any of those things. Nations are a way of making people proud of things that they did not do, and making people hate other people that they have never met.
- matt4077 10y agoAre you really denying that you're relying on the courts and police to – for example – protect your property?
- meanduck 10y agoYes I am. Police/Courts works because people are non-aggressive. And when you do get in trouble, Police/Courts should be last in your list of things that will help.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> You're welcome to move to a non taxation government, or just to one where it is barely enforced Even if you do that, the US will still tax you unless you also renounce your US citizenship. Which, incidentally, is not easy to do, and also requires paying a hefty fee (ie, "the tax you have to pay to get out of paying your tax").