5 ms·
Back in the 80's when all the Semiconductor companies were losing money, Andy Grove of Intel stated that because Intel was losing less money than everyone else,
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Back in the 80's when all the Semiconductor companies were losing money, Andy Grove of Intel stated that because Intel was losing less money than everyone else, it must be the largest semiconductor company. If Lyft can become profitable while Uber isn't that will change the market dynamics tremendously.
- wslh 10y agoBut Andy Grove made a strategic shift to stop losing money, he didn't continue with the same business.
- Inthenameofmine 10y agoYou mean their Intel's switch from RAM to CPUs? I have a feeling that something similar might end up happening here too. RAM was too much commoditized and cost-driven. CPUs were more IP driven. Finding a route from A to B with the right driver at a lower cost is cost driven as well. The self-driving car business will most likely have a very different cost structure. Just the other day I talked to the owner of a taxi company, going through their cost structure. We concluded that, if taxes are included, 90% of their costs can be reduced on a per-trip basis. It was his opinion that it would make the most sense that the future is some sort of public-private partnership model where the cars are owned by the city, but operated by some SaaS company, in order to get rid of taxes and further reduce costs. Without that tax reduction, he said we would see a similar situation as airplane ticket costs in the EU vs US (3-10x price difference due to taxes). Cities with 5-10x lower individual transport costs would actually have a competitive advantage. In the US this problem should be compounded as cities aren't as much cities as big villages with people thinly spread out. Thos cost reductions become even more important. It feels like Uber & Lyft are spending money on the wrong problem atm. This is just a transitionary stage in the transportation world.
- wslh 10y ago> You mean their Intel's switch from RAM to CPUs? Yes, and, like you, I think Uber & Lyft are wasting money in the wrong problem while the innovation landscape is quickly changing towards self-driving things.
- fragmede 10y agoGiven that Uber bought CMU's self-driving car research department, Uber might have some idea that "self-driving things" are coming.
- jayjay71 10y ago>Given that Uber bought CMU's self-driving car research department This is a common misconception. Uber poached several engineers from NREC, which technically belongs to CMU, but for all practical purposes is an independent entity. And of their original ~40 engineers, not many had any real previous experience on self-driving cars. Almost all of the engineers from the DARPA Grand/Urban Challenges had already left (many went to Google). NREC had nothing to do with any of those competitions. So what happened to CMU's self-driving car research department? Well, initially it was funded by GM. But it spun off into a company called Ottomatika which was later acquired by Delphi. Uber hired a bunch of great roboticists. They didn't hire a team that had any real experience with self-driving cars.
- wslh 10y ago> Uber might have some idea that "self-driving things" are coming. Self-driving things are being built everywhere, so I don't see the competitive advantage they have in AI because they built an app to get a car! Two very different things.
- jondubois 10y agoI don't think it's fair to compare Lyft with Intel in terms of innovation. Ride-sharing is not an area that can be monopolized. As soon as companies like Uber and Lyft stop subsidising rides, competitors will spawn up like mushrooms. Unless Uber/Lyft manage to create fully automated self-driving cars AND find a way to OWN all those cars, they will never have a monopoly. The people who own the cars will have the freedom to switch to any ride-sharing network they like (or even multiple networks). Then there will be new kinds of ride-finder apps which will allow people to select between multiple providers/networks - A bit like how Expedia lets you select between multiple airlines. The Airline business is very competitive and low-margin these days, I think it will be the same for companies like Lyft and Uber.
- coob 10y agoThat was the central premise behind Karhoo - an idea with a good long term future only to be seriously mismanaged at the senior level leading to failure.
- SomewhatLikely 10y agoGoogle maps at least on Android is already showing fares from both Uber and Lyft when you ask for directions.
- valarauca1 10y agoRide-sharing is not an area that can be monopolized I bet people said they said thing about silicon chip market in the 80's. But look where Intel is now. They have monopolized the desktop, server, and super computer markets.
- tim333 10y agoThere's a lot of cost in designing and making a modern microprocessor - many billion so it's hard to set up as a rival to Intel. Writing a taxi app less so. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13342415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13342415)
- 10y ago
- paulcole 10y ago>If Lyft can become profitable while Uber isn't that will change the market dynamics tremendously. if ifs and buts were candy and nuts, we'd all have a merry Christmas
- flylib 10y agoexcept they won't, Lyft is a lot smaller then Uber, Uber is around the world, Lyft is in one country and Lyft is starting global expansion this year which will increase losses