3 ms·
I've got a lot of mixed emotions about this. It was interesting that CBS aired a story on Friday about the 'first female ring master'[1] and then it drops that
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I've got a lot of mixed emotions about this. It was interesting that CBS aired a story on Friday about the 'first female ring master'[1] and then it drops that the show is closing.
An acquaintance of mine from grade school has pretty tirelessly crusaded against circuses for their mistreatment of animals. And for them, even the notion that you could "take excellent care" of an animal in your care that your raised from birth is an abomination if that animal is not allowed to run free in their original habitat (not that they would survive at that point but still...) But I've always enjoyed people pushing themselves to the edge to see if they can. As a result high wire acts, trapezes, and even the clown routines are fond memories for me.
If I'm honest with myself though it is just nostalgia for a different time. That time is past, whether or not there is a circus to go to.
[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/ringling-brothers-woman-ringmaster-first-kristen-michelle-wilson/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/ringling-brothers-woman-ringmast...
- marricks 10y agoI'm also against circuses massively, pushing people to their limits is fine and great if people are up for it, animals taken from their environment just to entertain us? Less so. If we want to "enjoy" an animal it should be on their terms. We have Circu De Soleil now though, right? They don't use animals and do some amazing things. I'm not sure what there is to morn.
- slfnflctd 10y ago> animals taken from their environment just to entertain us? Funny thing-- it's not too much of a stretch to extend this to pet ownership, as well. I have mixed feelings about all of it, honestly, but since these are essentially intractable problems at this point in time, I believe it comes down to how each individual animal is treated. I certainly think it's quite possible to have a large, 'exotic' animal who is trained to perform from birth to be happy and have a decent quality of life, just as I think the same is possible for that puppy or kitty adopted by someone you know. It seems clear to me that neither is ideal, but there are plenty of examples of better and worse situations. It's not black & white. Regardless, in my view, anyone concerned enough to protest the treatment of animals in circuses and/or zoos is being hypocritical if they're not working just as hard (or harder) to end the suffering of all the other sentient creatures we subject to 'unnatural' conditions on a vastly larger scale. Right now, the best we can seem do is keep saying "spay and neuter" like we have for at least half a century, and too many people still don't even seem to be getting that utterly basic message.
- waylandsmithers 10y agoSurely you don't mean dogs! Long history of evolving from grey wolves living alongside people in mutually beneficial ways.
- bb611 10y ago> Regardless, in my view, anyone concerned enough to protest the treatment of animals in circuses and/or zoos is being hypocritical if they're not working just as hard (or harder) to end the suffering of all the other sentient creatures we subject to 'unnatural' conditions on a vastly larger scale. It's unreasonable to expect someone to solve all problems at once. If you went to work and your boss complained you weren't working on enough problems, you'd likely tell them that you need to focus on the most pressing or solvable issue first, and yet you're saying the opposite about this group of people. Making a decision to focus on one element of the problem in order to move towards a solution is what practical people who solve problems do. Calling them hypocritical for not solving the (massive) related problem of animals as a human food source isn't reasonable.
- slfnflctd 10y agoFrom an engineering perspective, the 'best' long term approaches are those which produce either the largest number or largest percentage of desired outcomes. Also, getting people to change their historical mindset is a big part of effecting progress. To me, if you get people treating their pets and food animals better, 'performing' or 'display' animals would follow course. Singling out one species with a tiny number of members in a very unusual and rare use case may be great for splashy awareness campaigns, but unless whoever you're making more aware is also likely to carry that over into their treatment of other animals, I feel like you've fundamentally failed to begin to address the biggest part of the root problem.
- bb611 10y ago> From an engineering perspective, the 'best' long term approaches are those which produce either the largest number or largest percentage of desired outcomes. Given that activists have been working on this for several decades, what would you have done differently, and how would it have been more successful given the same resources? > Also, getting people to change their historical mindset is a big part of effecting progress. Would you say that getting people to change their historical mindset such that they no longer countenance animals being used for circus entertainment progress?
- VLM 10y ago"an abomination if that animal is not allowed to run free in their original habitat" So I'm abusing my kids if I don't air drop them in the Rift Valley in Africa and hope for the best.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is of course the logical extreme of the argument. I too don't agree with it, and wonder what will happen when we discover a species that has evolved to live only in EPA Superfund sites, do we destroy its habitat by cleaning up the pollution or do we preserve the species and leave the planet polluted? Both arguments speak to the futility of arguing staticism in an evolving world.
- crpatino 10y agoNo, because humans were not meant to be cut off from their community and dropped in the wild. Human children, in particular, are less prepared to cope with the dangers of being isolated early in life, compared with the way other mammal species are. Your example is about as accurate as saying that the circus owners are abusing their animals by not paying them a fair wage.